Westminster City Council v Unison

[2001] EWCA Civ 404

Case details

Case citations
[2001] EWCA Civ 404
Court
Court of Appeal (Civil Division)
Judgment date
20 March 2001
Judgment text

This feature is available to zoomLaw Pro members.

Subjects
Civil procedure Injunctions
Keywords
injunction discharge of injunction appeal reserved reasons
Outcome
injunction ordered to be discharged
Judicial consideration

This feature is available to zoomLaw Pro members.

Summary

The supplied transcript records an appellate court’s announcement that an injunction ordered below would be discharged. It contains no substantive reasons, statutory analysis, treatment of authorities, or durable proposition of law. The court stated that reasons would be given the following day.

Factual background

This was an appeal from the Queen’s Bench Division before HHJ Brunning. On 20 March 2001, the Court of Appeal announced that it proposed to discharge the injunction ordered by the judge. The transcript records no further facts, the grounds of appeal, or the central legal issue. Reasons were to be given at 10.30 the following day.

Held

  1. The Court of Appeal announced that the injunction ordered by the judge below would be discharged.
  2. The court did not give its reasons in the supplied transcript. Lord Justice Pill stated that reasons would be delivered at 10.30 the following day.
  3. The supplied text contains no analysis of the underlying dispute, statutory provisions, cited authorities, costs, or any further formal order.

The court’s approach to earlier authorities

This feature is available to zoomLaw Pro members.

Appellate history

  • Court of Appeal (Civil Division): On appeal from the Queen’s Bench Division before HHJ Brunning, the court announced that the injunction ordered below would be discharged. Reasons were reserved for the following day.

Lower court decision

Judgment appealed:
Not stated in the judgment
Outcome:
injunction ordered to be discharged

Key cases cited

This feature is available to zoomLaw Pro members.

Cases citing this case

This feature is available to zoomLaw Pro members.