Ukraine v The Law Debenture Trust Corporation Plc (Rev 1)

[2018] EWCA Civ 2026

Summary

A recognised foreign state has, in English law, unlimited capacity to contract under English law. Limits in its domestic law ordinarily concern the authority of those acting for it, rather than its capacity.

A contract governed by English law may be avoided for duress where illegitimate pressure caused its making. In relations between states, sufficiently determinate rules of international law, including peremptory norms, may inform whether pressure was illegitimate. The foreign act of state doctrine does not bar that defence where the public-policy exception applies. A state seeking to enforce English-law contractual rights cannot ordinarily prevent scrutiny of an arguable duress defence based on its own alleged breach of a peremptory international norm.

Terms preventing enforcement or hindrance of performance are not readily implied into tradeable debt instruments where they would be uncertain, depend on external relations, or undermine transferability.

Treatment over time

Cited in 12 later judgments between 2019 and 2024. Applied, followed or approved 5 times, most recently by the High Court in May 2023.

Most often cited for

  1. Foreign act of state may yield where public policy and comity favour adjudication3 judgments

Factual background

Ukraine issued tradeable English-law notes with a principal value of US$3 billion. Russia was the sole subscriber and beneficial holder. Law Debenture, as trustee, sought payment after Ukraine did not redeem the notes at maturity.

Blair J granted summary judgment for US$3.075 billion plus interest: [2017] EWHC 655 (Comm). Ukraine appealed, relying on lack of capacity or authority, duress arising from alleged Russian threats and pressure, implied terms, countermeasures, and the need for a trial. Law Debenture also contended that Ukraine had ratified or affirmed the transaction.

The central issue was whether Ukraine had an arguable, justiciable defence of duress under English law notwithstanding that its allegations concerned acts of a foreign state in international relations.

Held

  1. Appeal allowed in part. The court set aside the basis on which summary judgment had been entered because Ukraine had an arguable and justiciable defence of duress requiring trial. The appeal otherwise failed.

  2. A recognised sovereign state is a sui generis legal person in English law. Its domestic constitution and laws do not limit its English-law capacity to make and perform a contract. Those laws may instead limit the actual or ostensible authority of its officials. Ukraine therefore lacked no capacity to issue the notes.

  3. The court upheld the conclusion that Ukraine was bound through ostensible authority. The proper source of that authority was article 16.1 of the Budget Code of Ukraine, not a freestanding category of usual authority. Law Debenture was taken to know the public Ukrainian legislation, but it had no notice of the factual breaches of the borrowing limit or internal procedures alleged by Ukraine. The court rejected Law Debenture’s separate argument that the Cabinet could confer an authority contrary to the express statutory allocation of functions.

  4. Ukraine’s defence of duress had a domestic foothold because English law treats a contract made under illegitimate pressure as avoidable. International-law obligations could supply the applicable standard of illegitimacy in dealings between states. Although the alleged threats were prima facie high-policy foreign acts, the public-policy exception to the third foreign act of state rule applied. Material considerations included the English governing-law and jurisdiction clauses, the need to decide the contractual claim fairly, manageable legal standards, and the strong policy against a state benefiting from an alleged breach of a jus cogens norm reflected in Article 2(4) of the Charter of the United Nations.

  5. The international-law doctrine of countermeasures supplied no independent domestic-law defence. Ratification and affirmation raised factual and legal issues unsuitable for summary determination.

  6. The proposed implied terms failed the strict test for implication. They were not necessary, obvious or sufficiently certain, and would be incompatible with the character of the notes as tradeable financial instruments.

The court’s approach to earlier authorities

Available to signed-in members.

Appellate history

  • Court of Appeal (Civil Division): appeal allowed in part in [2018] EWCA Civ 2026 . Ukraine’s duress defence was held justiciable and triable; the remaining appealed issues were dismissed.
  • High Court, Commercial Court, Financial List: Blair J granted Law Debenture summary judgment under CPR 24.2 for US$3.075 billion plus interest: [2017] EWHC 655 (Comm) .

Appeal route

  1. Appealed from · 29 March 2017The Law Debenture Trust Corporation PLC v Ukraine, Represented By the Minister of Finance of Ukraine Acting Upon the Instructions of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine (Rev 1)[2017] EWHC 655 (Comm) High Court (Commercial Court)Partly reversedAppeal allowed in part (summary judgment could not stand because the duress defence required trial; other grounds dismissed)
  2. This judgment · 14 September 2018 [2018] EWCA Civ 2026 Court of Appeal (Civil Division)
  3. Appealed to · 15 March 2023The Law Debenture Trust Corporation plc v Ukraine (represented by the Minister of Finance of Ukraine acting upon the instructions of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine)[2023] UKSC 11 United Kingdom Supreme CourtUpheld this judgmentBoth appeals dismissed (by a majority; lord carnwath dissenting in part)

Other judgments in these proceedings

4 judgments in these proceedings, earliest first. Linked by appeals and by the court numbers the judgments share.

  1. 29 March 2017The Law Debenture Trust Corporation PLC v Ukraine, Represented By the Minister of Finance of Ukraine Acting Upon the Instructions of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine (Rev 1)[2017] EWHC 655 (Comm) · High Court (Commercial Court)
  2. 26 July 2017The Law Debenture Trust Corporation Plc v Ukraine[2017] EWHC 1902 (Comm) · High Court (Commercial Court)
  3. 14 September 2018Ukraine v The Law Debenture Trust Corporation Plc (Rev 1)[2018] EWCA Civ 2026 · Court of Appeal (Civil Division) · this judgment
  4. 15 March 2023The Law Debenture Trust Corporation plc v Ukraine (represented by the Minister of Finance of Ukraine acting upon the instructions of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine)[2023] UKSC 11 · Supreme Court

Cases on related points

Of these 8 cases: 2 cited alongside it for other points; 6 related in other ways.

Cited alongside it for other points

  1. Belhaj and another v Straw and others[2017] UKSC 3 · United Kingdom Supreme CourtThe distinct rules comprising the foreign act of state doctrineCited together in 3 later judgments
  2. Marks and Spencer plc v BNP Paribas Securities Services Trust Company (Jersey) Limited and another[2015] UKSC 72 · United Kingdom Supreme CourtImplied terms require necessity or obviousness, clear expression and consistency with express termsCited together in 3 later judgments

Other related cases

  1. Secure Capital SA v Credit Suisse AG[2015] EWHC 388 (Comm) · High Court (Commercial Court)Relies on 2 of the same authorities

+5 more for signed-in readers

Key cases cited

The 30 most senior of 48 authorities cited.

Sign in to see how the court treated each authority and the other 18. A free account is enough.

Cases citing this case

12 later cases · 5 positive · 4 neutral · 3 caution

Most senior citing decisions:

Sign in for the full treatment table, including the other 2 cases. A free account is enough.