Summary
A claim under section 423 of the Insolvency Act 1986 may have a sufficient connection with England even though the challenged transfers and parties are abroad. The court assesses all the circumstances. An alleged attempt to frustrate anticipated awards in London arbitrations under pre-existing English law contracts can supply the necessary connection.
For the tort of procuring a wrongful violation of rights under a judgment, conduct months or years before an award, and before substantive hearings, is insufficient. The court left open the position where conduct immediately precedes judgment after circulation of a draft.
On a challenge to permission to serve out, the relevant position is that at the date of the original order. Later evidence may be considered insofar as it illuminates that position.
Factual background
The claimants, headed by the State Oil Company of the Republic of Azerbaijan, were creditors under two awards made in London-seated arbitrations. The award debtors included Mubariz Mansimov, the founder of the Palmali group, and Palmali Holding Company Limited. The claimants alleged that restructurings involving Mr Mansimov and other defendants transferred assets for nominal consideration to frustrate enforcement.
The claimants brought claims under section 423 of the Insolvency Act 1986, for procuring non-payment of the awards and in unlawful means conspiracy. The defendants applied to set aside permission to serve the claim outside the jurisdiction. The principal issues were whether the claims had a real prospect of success, whether they passed through jurisdictional gateways and whether England was clearly the appropriate forum.
Held
The application to set aside permission to serve out was dismissed, save in relation to the claim based on the Marex tort.
- The section 423 claim raised serious issues to be tried. Evidence based on the group's last published accounts supported more than nominal value in the transferred assets. The disputed valuation and consideration could not be resolved by a mini-trial. The alleged absence of a legitimate commercial purpose, the lack of contemporaneous evidence of banking demands, the timing of the transfers and evidence of continuing beneficial ownership supported an arguable prohibited purpose. Notice of claims did not itself create a presumption of that purpose.
- There was a sufficient connection with England for the section 423 claim. The court considered all the circumstances, including the foreign parties and transfers. The underlying agreements were governed by English law and required London arbitration. Those arbitrations were imminent or underway when the restructurings took place. On the pleaded case, the transfers sought to frustrate anticipated English awards. Orexim Trading Ltd v Mahavir Port and Terminal Pte Ltd [2018] EWCA Civ 1660 was distinguishable: the asserted English connection there arose after the challenged transactions. Later conduct relied on as a new connecting factor was excluded from the assessment of the original permission order.
- The claim based on procuring wrongful violation of rights under an award had no real prospect of success on the pleaded facts. Even assuming the tort applied to awards, the challenged conduct occurred months or years before the awards and, in part, before arbitration began. The court left open the difficult position where conduct immediately precedes judgment after circulation of a draft. A separate claim for inducing breach of contract had not been pleaded.
- The conspiracy claim raised a serious issue insofar as its alleged unlawful means rested on section 423, but not insofar as they rested on the Marex tort. The section 423 claim passed through the statutory-claim gateway, and the conspiracy claim through the further-claim gateway.
- England was clearly the appropriate forum. The English law contracts and London arbitrations were central to the claims, while the restructurings spanned several jurisdictions. The defendants' participation in other English proceedings also informed the practical assessment. Their limited undertaking to submit to Turkish jurisdiction did not materially alter the balance.
The court’s approach to earlier authorities
Available to signed-in members.
Appellate history
At first instance, Jacobs J granted permission to serve the claim out of the jurisdiction on 6 June 2025. The defendants applied to set that order aside. The present application succeeded only in relation to the claim based on the Marex tort.
Cases on related points
- Zufi Alexander v Century Financial Brokers LLC & OrsRelies on 2 of the same authorities
- Suppipaj & Ors v Narongdej & OrsRelies on 2 of the same authorities
- Glas Sas (London Branch) v European Topsoho S.À R.L. & OrsRelies on 4 of the same authorities
5 more related cases for signed-in readers. A free account is enough.
Key provisions considered
Key cases cited
15 authorities cited.
- Four Seasons Holdings Incorporated v Brownlie [2017] UKSC 80
- AK Investment CJSC v Kyrgyz Mobil Tel Limited and others (Isle of Man) [2011] UKPC 7
- Spiliada Maritime Corpn v Cansulex Ltd (The Spiliada) [1987] AC 460
- Tulip Trading Limited (a Seychelles company) v Wladimir Jasper van der Laan & Ors. [2023] EWCA Civ 83
- Kaefer Aislamientos SA De CV v AMS Drilling Mexico SA De CV & Ors [2019] EWCA Civ 10
- Orexim Trading Ltd v Mahavir Port And Terminal Private Ltd & Ano [2018] EWCA Civ 1660
- JSC BTA Bank v Ablyazov & Anor [2018] EWCA Civ 1176
- Rana Al-Aggad v Talal Al-Aggad & Ors [2024] EWHC 673 (Comm)
- Commercial Bank of Dubai PSC & Ors v Abdalla Juma Majid Al Sari & Ors [2023] EWHC 1797 (Comm)
- Integral Petroleum S.A. V Petrogat FZE & Ors. [2023] EWHC 44 (Comm)
- Lakatamia Shipping Co Limited v Nobu Su (aka Su Hsin Chi; aka Nobu Morimoto) & Ors. [2021] EWHC 1907 (Comm)
- Integral Petroleum SA v Petrogat FZA & Ors [2021] EWHC 1365 (Comm)
- Marex Financial Ltd v Garcia [2017] EWHC 918 (Comm)
- Dornoch Ltd & Ors v Westminster International BV & Ors [2009] EWHC 1782 (Admlty)
- In re Paramount Airways Ltd (Powdrill v Hambros Bank (Jersey) Ltd) [1993] Ch 223
Sign in to see how the court treated each authority. A free account is enough.
Cases citing this case
Available to signed-in members.