Summary
A claimant seeking or maintaining a freezing injunction must show a good arguable case. That test does not require the claimant to have much the better of the argument. The court must consider a proposed limitation defence, but should not conduct a mini-trial on disputed facts at an interlocutory stage.
The reflective-loss principle prevents a parent company recovering loss which merely reflects loss suffered by subsidiaries. A subsidiary’s possible time bar does not itself remove that bar. The narrow exception where a wrongdoer has made it impossible for the company to sue does not apply merely because fraud was concealed or a limitation defence is asserted.
Treatment over time
Cited in 30 later judgments between 2015 and 2025. Applied, followed or approved 23 times, most recently by the High Court in October 2025. 1 negative treatment, by the High Court in 2021.
Most often cited for
- Freezing-order non-disclosure applications require proportionate assessment without a preliminary trial of disputed facts
- Freezing injunctions require a good arguable case, not the jurisdictional test of much the better argument
Factual background
Kazakhstan Kagazy Plc and associated group companies alleged that former directors had procured two major frauds involving construction projects in Kazakhstan. They obtained a without-notice freezing injunction against Mr Arip.
On an application to discharge it, the Commercial Court held that the subsidiary claimants had a good arguable answer to a Kazakh limitation defence, but reduced the frozen amount because one limb of the claim was insufficiently arguable. It also held that the parent’s claim was barred by reflective loss, and maintained the injunction despite limited non-disclosure. Mr Arip appealed and the claimants cross-appealed on reflective loss and costs: [2013] EWHC 3618 (Comm).
The central issues were the good-arguable-case threshold, reflective loss, and disclosure on a without-notice freezing-injunction application.
Held
Appeal and cross-appeal dismissed. The subsidiary claimants retained their freezing injunction. The Court would not disturb the Commercial Court judge’s evaluative conclusion that they had a good arguable answer to the limitation defence.
A freezing injunction requires a good arguable case. The judge had put the threshold too high by requiring the claimants to have much the better of the argument. The court must consider both the claim and any proposed defence, including limitation. However, disputed issues as to when a claimant ought to have become aware of fraud should ordinarily be resolved at trial, not by a mini-trial on an interlocutory application.
The parent company had no good arguable independent claim. Its alleged loss merely reflected the losses of subsidiaries which had brought the same claims. A possible limitation bar affecting those subsidiaries did not displace the reflective-loss principle. The limited exception in Giles v Rhind, [2003] Ch 618, requires the wrongdoer’s conduct to have disabled the company from pursuing its remedy. Concealment of fraud did not satisfy that condition, particularly as the subsidiaries had in fact sued.
The judge was entitled to maintain the injunction despite limited failures of disclosure. In a complex case, an application to set aside an order for non-disclosure should not become a preliminary trial of disputed facts. Materiality is a matter of degree and proportionality. Elias LJ added that matters raising suspicion may sometimes require disclosure, but the duty did not require a detailed analysis of every possible inference relevant to the limitation defence.
The judge’s costs order, reserving the costs below, was a discretionary decision within the proper range and was not varied.
The court’s approach to earlier authorities
Available to signed-in members.
Appellate history
- Court of Appeal (Civil Division): Dismissed Mr Arip’s appeal against the continuation of the freezing injunction and dismissed the claimants’ cross-appeal concerning reflective loss and costs: [2014] EWCA Civ 381 .
- High Court, Commercial Court: Refused to discharge the without-notice freezing injunction, while reducing its amount; held that the parent company had no independent claim because of reflective loss; and reserved costs: [2013] EWHC 3618 (Comm) .
Appeal route
- Appealed from · 20 November 2013Kazakhstan Kagazy Plc & Ors v Zhunus & Ors[2013] EWHC 3618 (Comm) High Court (Commercial Court)UpheldAppeal dismissed; cross-appeal dismissed
- This judgment · 2 April 2014 [2014] EWCA Civ 381 Court of Appeal (Civil Division)
Other judgments in these proceedings
4 judgments in these proceedings, earliest first. Linked by appeals and by the court numbers the judgments share.
- 20 November 2013Kazakhstan Kagazy Plc & Ors v Zhunus & Ors
- 2 April 2014Kazakhstan Kagazy Plc & Ors v Arip
- 20 February 2015Kazakhstan Kagazy Plc & Ors v Zhunus & Ors
- 29 September 2016Kazakhstan Kagazy Plc & Ors v Zhunus & Ors
Often cited alongside this case
Of these 8 cases: 6 cited with it on 2 different points; 1 cited alongside it for another point; 1 related in other ways.
Cited together forFreezing-order non-disclosure applications require proportionate assessment without a preliminary trial of disputed facts
- Tugushev v Orlov & Ors (No. 2)Cited together in 9 later judgments
+2 more for signed-in readers
Cited together forFreezing injunctions require a good arguable case, not the jurisdictional test of much the better argument
- Chowgule & Company Private Ltd & Anor v Pratap Shirke & OrsCited together in 3 later judgments
+2 more for signed-in readers
Cited alongside it for other points
1 related case for signed-in readers
Other related cases
- Holyoake & Anor v Candy & OrsCited together in 4 later judgments
5 more related cases for signed-in readers. A free account is enough.
Key cases cited
6 authorities cited.
- Johnson v Gore Wood & Co [2002] 2 AC 1
- Barnstaple Boat Co Ltd v Jones [2008] 1 All ER 1124
- Giles v Rhind [2002] EWCA Civ 1428
- Day v Cook [2002] 1 BCLC 1
- Crown Resources AG v Vinogradsky 15 June 2001
- Rasu Maritima SA v Perusahaan Pertambangan Minyak Dan Gas Bumi Negara (Government of the Republic of Indonesia intervening) (Pertamina) [1978] QB 644
Sign in to see how the court treated each authority. A free account is enough.
Cases citing this case
30 later cases · 23 positive · 3 neutral · 3 caution · 1 negative
Most senior citing decisions:
- Astor Asset Management 3 Limited & Ors v Ricardo Benjamin Salinas Pliego & Anor [2025] EWCA Civ 1060 explained
- Mold Investments Limited v Matthew Joseph Holloway [2025] EWCA Civ 986 applied
- Isabel Dos Santos v Unitel S.A. [2024] EWCA Civ 1109 followed
- MEX Group Worldwide Limited v Stewart Owen Ford & Ors [2024] EWCA Civ 959
- Derma Med Limited & Anor v Dr Zack Ally & Ors [2024] EWCA Civ 175
- JSC Commercial Bank Privatbank v Kolomoisky & Ors [2019] EWCA Civ 1708
- Wenda Co Limited v Wang Jinhong & Ors [2025] EWHC 2648 (Comm)
- Ashford Borough Council v Mark Homewood & Anor [2025] EWHC 607 (KB)
- Ricardo Benjamin Salinas Pliego & Anor v Astor Asset Management 3 Ltd & Ors [2024] EWHC 2522 (Comm)
- Ziyavudin Magomedov & Ors v Konstantin Kuzovkov & Ors [2024] EWHC 2527 (Comm)
Sign in for the full treatment table, including the other 20 cases. A free account is enough.