Harb v HRH Prince Abdul Aziz Bin Fahd Bin Abdul Aziz

[2016] EWCA Civ 556

Summary

Where a civil claim turns substantially on disputed oral evidence, the judgment must address the essential issues, evaluate the principal challenges to credibility, test the evidence against contemporaneous documents and inherent probabilities, and explain the findings. A blanket preference for one witness is insufficient, particularly where evidence from both sides has significant weaknesses.

In deciding whether an alleged representative assumed personal contractual liability, the court must determine what the parties said and objectively understood about the capacity in which that person acted. The existence of general authority is not the decisive question.

Apparent bias is assessed objectively through the fair-minded and informed observer, who knows all relevant circumstances. Hostility towards an advocate does not, without more, establish a real possibility of bias against the advocate’s client.

Treatment over time

Cited in 18 later judgments between 2016 and 2025. Applied, followed or approved 14 times, most recently by the Court of Appeal in December 2025.

Most often cited for

  1. The fair-minded and informed observer is objective and distinct from the litigant12 judgments
  2. Judgments must address essential issues and principal credibility challenges5 judgments

Factual background

The claimant alleged that the defendant Prince had orally agreed to pay her £12 million and procure the transfer of two properties if she withdrew allegations concerning the late King Fahd. Her primary case was that a binding contract arose during a meeting at the Dorchester Hotel. Alternatively, she alleged that it arose when the Prince later requested and received original documents prepared to implement the arrangement.

Peter Smith J found for the claimant on both bases and held that the Prince had contracted personally rather than as the King’s agent: [2015] EWHC 3155 (Ch). The Prince appealed, challenging the findings about the contract, personal liability, the treatment of his failure to attend for cross-examination, and apparent bias.

The central issues were whether the judge had adequately analysed the disputed evidence and the capacity in which the Prince allegedly acted, and whether the circumstances created an appearance of bias.

Held

  1. Appeal allowed and retrial ordered. The judge had failed to examine the evidence and arguments with the care required for a proper resolution of the issues. The deficiencies were sufficiently serious that the judgment could not stand. The claim was remitted to the High Court for retrial before a different judge.

  2. Evidence on a disputed factual question which has not been tested in cross-examination will almost inevitably carry less weight. That fact did not, however, justify a blanket preference for the opposing witnesses whenever their accounts conflicted. The judge had to assess the evidence issue by issue, testing it against contemporaneous documents, other evidence and inherent probabilities. The judge also wrongly inferred, without adequately addressing the diplomatic correspondence, that the Prince had stayed away merely to avoid cross-examination.

  3. Where a case largely depends on oral evidence and the credibility of a principal witness is challenged on several grounds, the judgment must address at least the principal challenges. It must identify the essential questions, analyse the significant strands of evidence and explain the findings. The trial judge did not adequately confront the serious problems with the claimant’s evidence, the possible interpretations of the documents, whether dealings were subject to contract, or whether the alleged agreement was intended immediately to create legal relations. Those omissions undermined the fairness of the trial.

  4. The judge also asked the wrong question concerning agency. The material issue was not whether the Prince possessed general authority from the King. It was whether the claimant approached him in a representative capacity and whether anything said or done led her reasonably to understand that he assumed a personal obligation. That issue was inseparable from the questions of what was said and whether a binding agreement arose. It required detailed factual analysis which the judgment did not provide.

  5. Although unnecessary to the disposition, the court rejected the apparent-bias ground. Applying Porter v Magill [2002] 2 AC 357, the question was whether the fair-minded and informed observer, considering all relevant circumstances, would find a real possibility of bias. The test was objective and differed from the subjective reaction of a litigant. Even if the judge’s letter indicated temporary hostility towards members of the Prince’s counsel’s chambers, hostility towards an advocate does not without more establish possible bias against the client. The chronology made it unrealistic to conclude that the challenged article had influenced the decision.

The court’s approach to earlier authorities

Available to signed-in members.

Appellate history

  1. Court of Appeal (Civil Division): The appeal was allowed in [2016] EWCA Civ 556 . The judgment below was set aside and the claim remitted to the High Court for retrial before a different judge. The separate allegation of apparent bias was rejected.
  2. High Court, Chancery Division: Peter Smith J found that a binding contract existed on both the claimant’s primary and alternative cases and that the defendant was personally liable: [2015] EWHC 3155 (Ch) .

Appeal route

  1. Appealed from · 3 November 2015Harb v HRC Prince Abdul Aziz Bin Fahd Bin Abdul Aziz[2015] EWHC 3155 (Ch) High Court (Chancery Division)ReversedAppeal allowed; judgment set aside and claim remitted for retrial before a different judge
  2. This judgment · 16 June 2016 [2016] EWCA Civ 556 Court of Appeal (Civil Division)

Other judgments in these proceedings

8 judgments in these proceedings, earliest first. Linked by appeals and by the court numbers the judgments share.

  1. 9 June 2014Harb v Prince Fahd Bin Abdul Aziz[2014] EWHC 1807 (Ch) · High Court (Chancery Division)
  2. 13 May 2015HRH Prince Abdul Aziz Bin Fahd Bin Abdul Aziz v Harb[2015] EWCA Civ 481 · Court of Appeal (Civil Division)
  3. 16 July 2015Harb v HRH Prince Abdul Aziz Bin Fahd Bin Abdul Aziz[2015] EWHC 2195 (Ch) · High Court (Chancery Division)
  4. 3 November 2015Harb v HRC Prince Abdul Aziz Bin Fahd Bin Abdul Aziz[2015] EWHC 3155 (Ch) · High Court (Chancery Division)
  5. 16 June 2016Harb v HRH Prince Abdul Aziz Bin Fahd Bin Abdul Aziz[2016] EWCA Civ 556 · Court of Appeal (Civil Division) · this judgment
  6. 21 February 2017Harb v HRH Prince Abdul Aziz Bin Fahd Bin Abdul Aziz[2017] EWHC 258 (Ch) · High Court (Chancery Division)
  7. 21 December 2017Prince Fahd Bin Abdul Aziz v Harb[2017] EWCA Civ 2215 · Court of Appeal (Civil Division)
  8. 16 March 2018Harb v HRH Prince Abdul Aziz Bin Fahd Bin Abdul Aziz[2018] EWHC 508 (Ch) · High Court (Chancery Division)

Cases on related points

Of these 8 cases: 2 cited with it on the same point; 4 cited alongside it for other points; 2 related in other ways.

Cited together forThe fair-minded and informed observer is objective and distinct from the litigant

  1. Virdi v The Law Society of England and Wales & Anor[2010] EWCA Civ 100 · Court of Appeal (Civil Division)Cited together in 3 later judgments
  2. Magill v Porter and Magill v Weeks[2001] UKHL 67 · House of LordsCited together in 11 later judgments

Cited alongside it for other points

  1. Morrison & Anor v AWG Group Ltd & Anor[2006] EWCA Civ 6 · Court of Appeal (Civil Division)Apparent bias requires automatic disqualification, regardless of inconvenience, cost or delayCited together in 3 later judgments

+3 more for signed-in readers

Other related cases

2 related cases for signed-in readers

Key cases cited

5 authorities cited.

Sign in to see how the court treated each authority. A free account is enough.

Cases citing this case

18 later cases · 14 positive · 4 caution

Most senior citing decisions:

Sign in for the full treatment table, including the other 8 cases. A free account is enough.