Quantum Actuarial LLP v Quantum Advisory Ltd

[2021] EWCA Civ 227

Summary

The restraint of trade doctrine has no single exhaustive threshold test. A court must first identify a practical restraint and then assess, by reference to public policy and all circumstances at contract formation, whether the restraint requires justification. The trading society approach is a guide, not a universal test.

A bespoke, freely negotiated commercial agreement may fall outside the doctrine where its restraints are fairly and properly ancillary to an agreed allocation of business and goodwill. If the doctrine applies, the restraint must protect legitimate private interests without injuring the public. A long duration is important but is assessed in its contractual and commercial setting.

Treatment over time

Cited in 13 later judgments between 2021 and 2026. Applied, followed or approved 12 times, most recently by the Court of Appeal in July 2026.

Most often cited for

  1. Restraint of trade is assessed flexibly by its practical effect, not rigid categories10 judgments
  2. Bargaining power and legal advice affect the weight given to parties’ assessments of reasonableness4 judgments
  3. The enforcing party must justify a restraint as reasonably necessary when the contract is made3 judgments

Factual background

Quantum Actuarial LLP was created during a restructuring of pensions-services businesses. Under a 99-year services agreement, it serviced legacy clients for a fee while the respondent retained the legacy goodwill and profit element. The agreement prevented the LLP from soliciting, accepting instructions from, or undertaking specified services for those clients otherwise than through the agreement.

The respondent sought declarations that the agreement was enforceable after the LLP asserted that the covenants were in unreasonable restraint of trade. HHJ Keyser QC, sitting as a High Court judge, held that the doctrine did not apply and that the covenants were reasonable in any event: [2020] EWHC 1072 (Comm). The LLP appealed on both issues.

Held

  1. Appeal dismissed unanimously. Lady Justice Carr gave the judgment, with whom Lord Justice Stuart-Smith and Lord Justice Moylan agreed.

  2. The court held that the doctrine of restraint of trade requires a three-stage analysis. The court first asks whether the covenant is a practical restraint on trading. If it is, the court asks whether public policy nevertheless requires the covenantee to justify it. Only if the doctrine is engaged does the court decide whether the restraint is reasonable between the parties and in the public interest.

  3. Peninsula Securities Ltd v Dunnes Stores (Bangor) Ltd [2020] UKSC 36 rejected the pre-existing-freedom test, but it did not replace the flexible common-law approach with a single universal trading society test. The relevant assessment is fact-sensitive, iterative and made at the date of contracting. Subsequent developments matter only as evidence of the contract's nature when made.

  4. The covenants were a literal practical restraint. However, the parties had freely negotiated a bespoke arrangement on equal terms. The agreement enabled the LLP to trade using an established business, brand and infrastructure, while preserving the legacy clients and goodwill for the respondent. The restraints were fairly and properly ancillary to that agreed allocation and were not oppressive or a special feature requiring justification. The public interest in enforcing the freely negotiated contract prevailed.

  5. In any event, the covenants satisfied the Nordenfelt test. They protected the legitimate boundary between the legacy business and the LLP's new business. Their duration matched the agreement which the LLP had proposed should last 99 years, and the restraints did not cause public harm. It was therefore unnecessary to decide the respondent's alternative agency and fiduciary-duty arguments.

The court’s approach to earlier authorities

Available to signed-in members.

Appellate history

  • Court of Appeal (Civil Division): dismissed the LLP's appeal and upheld the enforceability of the covenants: [2021] EWCA Civ 227 .

  • High Court, Circuit Commercial Court: held that the restraint of trade doctrine did not apply and that the covenants were reasonable in any event: [2020] EWHC 1072 (Comm) .

Appeal route

  1. Appealed from · 5 May 2020Quantum Advisory Ltd v Quantum Actuarial LLP[2020] EWHC 1072 (Comm) High Court (Commercial Court)UpheldAppeal dismissed (unanimously)
  2. This judgment · 24 February 2021 [2021] EWCA Civ 227 Court of Appeal (Civil Division)

Other judgments in these proceedings

2 judgments in these proceedings, earliest first. Linked by appeals and by the court numbers the judgments share.

  1. 5 May 2020Quantum Advisory Ltd v Quantum Actuarial LLP[2020] EWHC 1072 (Comm) · High Court (Commercial Court)
  2. 24 February 2021Quantum Actuarial LLP v Quantum Advisory Ltd[2021] EWCA Civ 227 · Court of Appeal (Civil Division) · this judgment

Related cases

Not part of these proceedings, but heard together with this judgment or between the same parties.

  1. 10 June 2022QUANTUM ADVISORY LIMITED v QUANTUM ACTUARIAL LLP[2022] EWHC 1423 (Ch) · High Court (Chancery Division) · Same parties
  2. 18 January 2023Quantum Advisory Limited v Quantum Actuarial LLP[2023] EWHC 47 (Ch) · High Court (Chancery Division) · Same parties
  3. 19 January 2023Quantum Advisory Limited v Quantum Actuarial LLP[2023] EWCA Civ 12 · Court of Appeal (Civil Division) · Same parties
  4. 5 June 2023Quantum Advisory Limited v Quantum Actuarial LLP[2023] EWHC 1338 (Ch) · High Court (Chancery Division) · Same parties
  5. 14 March 2024Quantum Advisory Limited v Quantum Actuarial LLP[2024] EWCA Civ 247 · Court of Appeal (Civil Division) · Same parties

Cases on related points

Of these 8 cases: 1 cited with it on one of its points; 5 cited alongside it for other points; 2 related in other ways.

Cited together forRestraint of trade is assessed flexibly by its practical effect, not rigid categories

  1. Esso Petroleum Co Ltd v Harper’s Garage (Stourport) Ltd[1968] AC 269 · House of LordsCited together in 5 later judgments

Cited alongside it for other points

  1. Peninsula Securities Ltd v Dunnes Stores (Bangor) Ltd[2020] UKSC 36 · United Kingdom Supreme CourtAccepted commercial practice identifies restraints outside the doctrine, though the test is difficult to applyCited together in 4 later judgments
  2. Chipsaway International Ltd v Kerr[2009] EWCA Civ 320 · Court of Appeal (Civil Division)A franchise restraint may protect territorial goodwill while a replacement franchise is establishedCited together in 3 later judgments

+3 more for signed-in readers

Other related cases

2 related cases for signed-in readers

Key cases cited

19 authorities cited.

Sign in to see how the court treated each authority. A free account is enough.

Cases citing this case

13 later cases · 12 positive · 1 neutral

Most senior citing decisions:

Sign in for the full treatment table, including the other 3 cases. A free account is enough.