Re: S (A Child)

[2023] EWCA Civ 208

Summary

When determining the article 13(b) exception to summary return, the court must assess the alleged risks cumulatively. The gravity of a risk depends both on its likelihood and on the seriousness of the potential harm.

Protective measures defeat the exception only where the evidence establishes that they would sufficiently ameliorate the grave risk. A mere possibility that they might do so leaves the risk in place. The jurisdiction requires a summary decision on the evidence at the hearing. It is not a continuing or “wait and see” jurisdiction.

Treatment over time

Cited in 10 later judgments between 2023 and 2026, including 1 in the Supreme Court. Applied, followed or approved 7 times, most recently by the Supreme Court in September 2026.

Most often cited for

  1. Mental-health consequences may be relevant to an Article 13(b) defence3 judgments
  2. Protective measures must be more effective as the need for protection increases3 judgments
  3. Hague Convention jurisdiction requires a summary decision, not a wait-and-see approach3 judgments

Factual background

The mother appealed against an unreported order of Arbuthnot J requiring the summary return of her six-year-old child from England to Australia under the 1980 Hague Child Abduction Convention. The mother had chronic mental-health difficulties and relied solely on the exception in article 13(b). Her older child, who was not subject to the proceedings, was to remain in England.

The judge found that, without protective measures, deterioration in the mother’s mental health would create a grave risk of psychological harm or an intolerable situation for the younger child. She nevertheless ordered return because proposed safeguards were considered sufficient. The central issue was whether that conclusion properly reflected the psychiatric evidence and the cumulative risks.

Held

  1. Appeal allowed. The order for summary return was set aside and the father’s application under the 1980 Hague Child Abduction Convention was dismissed.

  2. The article 13(b) assessment concerns both the likelihood of the identified risk and the nature of the harm should it occur. The first-instance judge had correctly found that, without protective measures, deterioration in the mother’s mental health would create a grave risk of psychological harm to the child or place him in an intolerable situation.

  3. The risks had to be assessed cumulatively. The judge considered the matters relied upon sequentially and did not combine the likely deterioration in the mother’s mental health with the established consequence that the child would be separated from his sibling. Separation alone did not establish article 13(b), but it provided additional support for the existence of a grave risk.

  4. The judge did not sufficiently engage with the psychiatrist’s evidence that the mother’s mental health had to stabilise before any return. The proposed measures did not address pre-return stabilisation. Nor did the evidence establish that they would prevent a serious deterioration. They were intended only to try to prevent deterioration to the extent previously experienced, and their effectiveness could not be predicted.

  5. Protective measures must be shown to reduce or sufficiently ameliorate the identified grave risk. Evidence that they might or might not do so is insufficient. The evidence therefore did not support the finding that professional support, medication, insurance, accommodation and other undertakings would ensure that the child avoided grave harm.

  6. The proceedings could not be adjourned pending stabilisation. The Convention requires a summary decision on the evidence existing at the hearing and does not confer a continuing, “wait and see” jurisdiction. The timing of any improvement was also impossible to predict.

  7. Although establishing article 13(b) gives the court a discretion, there was no justification for exercising it by ordering return. The grave risk remained and the summary return application was refused.

The court’s approach to earlier authorities

Available to signed-in members.

Appellate history

  1. Court of Appeal (Civil Division): By [2023] EWCA Civ 208 , unanimously allowed the mother’s appeal, set aside the summary return order and dismissed the father’s application.
  2. High Court, Family Division: Arbuthnot J made an unreported order for the child’s summary return to Australia, subject to undertakings and protective measures.

Appeal route

  1. Appealed fromNot stated in the judgmentThis appealappeal allowed (father’s application for summary return dismissed)
  2. This judgment · 28 February 2023 [2023] EWCA Civ 208 Court of Appeal (Civil Division)

Often cited alongside this case

Of these 8 cases: 1 cited with it on one of its points; 7 cited alongside it for other points.

Cited together forMental-health consequences may be relevant to an Article 13(b) defence

  1. Re A (Article 13(b): Mental Ill-health)[2023] EWHC 2082 (Fam) · High Court (Family Division)Cited together in 3 later judgments

Cited alongside it for other points

  1. Re B (Children)[2022] EWCA Civ 1171 · Court of Appeal (Civil Division)Article 13(b) allegations must be assessed cumulatively against available protective measuresCited together in 8 later judgments
  2. In the matter of S (A Child)[2012] UKSC 10 · United Kingdom Supreme CourtA parent’s objectively unreasonable return anxieties may create intolerable risk; their objective basis informs likely mental stateCited together in 8 later judgments

+5 more for signed-in readers

Key cases cited

4 authorities cited.

Sign in to see how the court treated each authority. A free account is enough.

Cases citing this case

10 later cases · 7 positive · 2 neutral · 1 caution

Most senior citing decisions:

Sign in for the full treatment table. A free account is enough.