Interdigital Technology Corporation & Ors v Lenovo Group Limited & Ors

[2024] EWCA Civ 743

Summary

When a court determines the terms of a global FRAND licence, national limitation periods do not exclude earlier sales. A willing licensee would pay a fair royalty from the first use of the standard and should gain no advantage from delay.

Interest on past royalties ordinarily forms part of FRAND terms because payment timing should be economically neutral. Comparable licences affected by non-FRAND market distortions require adjustment. The court must estimate an appropriate rate rather than assume that the precise rate extracted from the best comparable is itself FRAND.

Treatment over time

Cited in 11 later judgments between 2024 and 2026. Applied, followed or approved 7 times, most recently by the Court of Appeal in July 2026.

Most often cited for

  1. A global FRAND licence may cover all sales from first implementation, with interest on past royalties3 judgments

Factual background

InterDigital and Lenovo disputed the lump sum payable for a global licence of patents declared essential to ETSI’s 3G, 4G and 5G standards. Mellor J determined a royalty of $138.7 million for sales from 2007 to 2023 and awarded $46.2 million interest at 4% compounded quarterly: [2023] EWHC 538 (Pat) and [2023] EWHC 1578 (Pat).

InterDigital appealed against the royalty rate and sought a declaration that it had been a willing licensor. Lenovo cross-appealed, contending that pre-August 2013 sales should be excluded by reference to limitation principles and that interest should be removed or reduced. The central issues were the treatment of past sales, interest and distortions affecting comparable licences.

Held

  1. Disposition. InterDigital’s appeal was allowed in part. The unadjusted rate derived from the LG 2017 comparable was increased from $0.24 to $0.30 per unit, and the adjustment ratio was increased from 0.728 to 0.75. This produced a rate of $0.225 per Lenovo unit and a lump sum of $178.3 million. Lenovo’s cross-appeal was dismissed. The parties were directed to calculate interest at 4% compounded quarterly.
  2. Past sales and limitation. A willing licensee requires a licence from the first day it implements the standard and would agree to pay a fair royalty from that date. National limitation periods concern claims such as damages for tort or breach of contract. They do not determine the contractual price of a global FRAND licence or the terms an implementer must accept to avoid an injunction. Excluding older sales would reward delay and discriminate against prompt licensees. Truly egregious licensor conduct may instead be addressed through interest or costs: paras [186]-[205].
  3. Interest. Although no applicable statutory, equitable or ordinary contractual jurisdiction supplied interest, the court could include it because a willing licensor and willing licensee would agree that payment timing should be economically neutral. The same time-value principle used to discount future payments applies to past royalties. The judge was entitled to select the parties’ agreed late-payment rate of 4%, compounded quarterly: paras [208]-[227].
  4. Comparable licences. The judge’s use of the precise blended LG 2017 rate was internally inconsistent with his findings that non-FRAND factors had depressed consideration for past sales. The court had to correct that distortion. InterDigital’s proposed future-only rate of $0.61 was also excessive because future rates had been inflated to compensate for discounted past sales. Doing the best possible with the evidence, the highest justified FRAND rate for LG was $0.30, subject to a 0.75 adjustment for Lenovo: paras [251]-[284].
  5. Remaining grounds. The comparables analysis remained more reliable than InterDigital’s top-down cross-check. No declaration of past willingness was required because willingness no longer affected the only live question, namely the FRAND sum payable: paras [285]-[287]. Nugee LJ concurred in the result despite reservations about the comparable-rate issue. Birss LJ agreed with Arnold LJ and explained why the uncorrected $0.24 figure was necessarily too low.

The court’s approach to earlier authorities

Available to signed-in members.

Appellate history

  • Court of Appeal (Civil Division): By [2024] EWCA Civ 743 , allowed InterDigital’s appeal in part, substituted a $178.3 million lump sum before interest, and dismissed Lenovo’s cross-appeal.
  • High Court, Patents Court: Mellor J determined the principal FRAND terms in [2023] EWHC 538 (Pat), with public versions at [2023] EWHC 539 (Pat) and [2023] EWHC 1538 (Pat). He fixed a $138.7 million lump sum for sales from 2007 to 2023.
  • High Court, Patents Court: In [2023] EWHC 1578 (Pat) , Mellor J awarded $46.2 million interest at 4% compounded quarterly.

Appeal route

  1. Appealed fromUnknown case[2023] EWHC 538 (Pat) EWHCPartly reversedAppeal allowed in part; cross-appeal dismissed
  2. This judgment · 12 July 2024 [2024] EWCA Civ 743 Court of Appeal (Civil Division)

Other judgments in these proceedings

14 judgments in these proceedings, earliest first. Linked by appeals and by the court numbers the judgments share.

  1. 19 January 2021Interdigital Technology Corporation & Ors v Lenovo Group Ltd & Ors[2021] EWHC 89 (Pat) · High Court (Patents Court)
  2. 26 November 2021Interdigital Technology Corp v Lenovo Group Ltd[2021] EWHC 3192 (Pat) · High Court (Patents Court)
  3. 16 December 2021Interdigital Technology Corporation v Lenovo Group Limited[2021] EWHC 3401 (Pat) · High Court (Patents Court)
  4. 6 January 2022Interdigital Technology Corporation v Lenovo Group Limited[2022] EWHC 10 (Pat) · High Court (Patents Court)
  5. 19 January 2023InterDigital Technology Corporation & Ors v Lenovo Group Ltd & Ors[2023] EWCA Civ 34 · Court of Appeal (Civil Division)
  6. 30 January 2023InterDigital Technology Corporation & Ors v Lenovo Group Ltd & Ors[2023] EWCA Civ 57 · Court of Appeal (Civil Division)
  7. 31 January 2023Interdigital Technology Corporation & Ors v Lenovo Group Limited & Ors[2023] EWHC 172 (Pat) · High Court (Patents Court)
  8. 9 February 2023Interdigital Technology Corporation & Ors v Lenovo Group Limited & Ors[2023] EWCA Civ 105 · Court of Appeal (Civil Division)
  9. 16 March 2023Interdigital Technology Corporation & Ors. v Lenovo Group Limited & Ors.[2023] EWHC 539 (Pat) · High Court (Patents Court)
  10. 27 June 2023Interdigital Technology Corporation v Lenovo Group Limited[2023] EWHC 1578 (Pat) · High Court (Patents Court)
  11. 28 June 2023Interdigital Technology Corporation & Ors v Lenovo Group Limited & Ors[2023] EWHC 1577 (Pat) · High Court (Patents Court)
  12. 4 July 2023Interdigital Technology Corporation & Ors v Lenovo Group Limited & Ors[2023] EWHC 1583 (Pat) · High Court (Patents Court)
  13. 27 March 2024Interdigital Technology Corporation & Ors v Lenovo Group Limited & Ors[2024] EWHC 742 (Pat) · High Court (Patents Court)
  14. 12 July 2024Interdigital Technology Corporation & Ors v Lenovo Group Limited & Ors[2024] EWCA Civ 743 · Court of Appeal (Civil Division) · this judgment

Related cases

Not part of these proceedings, but heard together with this judgment or between the same parties.

  1. 21 March 2024Lenovo Group Limited & Ors v Interdigital Technology Corporation & Ors[2024] EWHC 596 (Ch) · High Court (Chancery Division) · Same parties
  2. 25 April 2024Lenovo Group Limited & Ors v Interdigital Technology Corporation & Ors[2024] EWHC 1036 (Pat) · High Court (Patents Court) · Same parties
  3. 24 July 2024Lenovo Group Limited & Ors v Interdigital Technology Corporation & Ors[2024] EWHC 1922 (Pat) · High Court (Patents Court) · Same parties

Often cited alongside this case

Of these 8 cases: 1 cited with it on one of its points; 5 cited alongside it for other points; 2 related in other ways.

Cited together forA global FRAND licence may cover all sales from first implementation, with interest on past royalties

1 related case for signed-in readers

Cited alongside it for other points

  1. Teva UK Limited & Anor v Novartis AG[2022] EWCA Civ 1617 · Court of Appeal (Civil Division)An English court should not declare foreign-law issues solely to influence a foreign courtCited together in 4 later judgments
  2. Optis Cellular Technology LLC & Ors. v Apple Retail U.K. Limited & Ors.[2022] EWCA Civ 1411 · Court of Appeal (Civil Division)An infringer must commit to court-determined FRAND terms to avoid an injunctionCited together in 4 later judgments

+3 more for signed-in readers

Other related cases

  1. Unwired Planet International Ltd v Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd & Anor (Rev 2)[2017] EWHC 2988 (Pat) · High Court (Patents Court)Cited together in 5 later judgments

+1 more for signed-in readers

Key cases cited

19 authorities cited.

Sign in to see how the court treated each authority. A free account is enough.

Cases citing this case

11 later cases · 7 positive · 3 neutral · 1 caution

Most senior citing decisions:

Sign in for the full treatment table, including the other 1 cases. A free account is enough.