Summary
The discretion to award pre-judgment interest on costs extends to compensating a receiving party who is liable to compensate another person for providing legal services on credit. Actual payment of costs or borrowing by the receiving party is unnecessary. A contingent success fee which includes compensation for deferred payment can establish the relevant liability.
Such interest is distinct from recovery of the success fee prohibited by section 58A(6) of the Courts and Legal Services Act 1990. The liability triggers consideration of interest; it does not determine its amount. Interest reflects the reasonable funding cost for the relevant class of litigant. The court should take a broad approach, without ordinarily examining the funding arrangements minutely. An award is neither exceptional nor confined to unusual cases.
Factual background
Approximately 450,000 individuals, businesses, municipalities and other entities claimed compensation from BHP Group (UK) Ltd and BHP Group Limited for losses allegedly caused by the collapse of the Fundão Dam in Brazil. Following the Stage 1 trial, O’Farrell J held BHP liable under Brazilian law and rejected its limitation defence. Permission to appeal those substantive decisions was refused.
In [2026] EWHC 73 (TCC), the judge ordered BHP to pay 90% of the claimants’ Stage 1 costs, together with pre-judgment interest at 1% above UK base rate from 1 August 2023 to 26 January 2026. The claimants’ solicitors, Pogust Goodhead, acted under conditional fee agreements. The court proceeded on the agreed assumption that the claimants would become liable upon success for base costs and success fees which partly compensated the solicitors for providing services without immediate payment.
BHP appealed the interest award. It argued that interest required actual expenditure or borrowing by the claimants and that the award indirectly recovered prohibited success fees. The central issue was whether the discretion to award pre-judgment interest encompassed a contingent liability for legal services supplied on credit, consistently with the statutory prohibition on recovering success fees.
Held
Appeal dismissed unanimously. Sir Geoffrey Vos MR gave the leading judgment, with which Zacaroli and Cockerill LJJ agreed.
The power under CPR rule 44.2(6)(g) conferred a broad discretion to compensate for the loss of the time value of money. It covered both a receiving party who had been kept out of its money and one liable to compensate another person for providing legal services on credit. That person could be the solicitors, an insurer or a third-party funder. Requiring actual expenditure or borrowing by the receiving party would impose an unwarranted restriction on the discretion ([35]–[38]).
The court could proceed on the agreed assumption that the claimants’ success fees included an element compensating their solicitors for funding costs. The contingent nature of that liability did not prevent an interest award. Applications should not ordinarily require a minute examination of the funding mechanism. The court should make a general appraisal of what was reasonable between the paying and receiving parties, and pre-judgment interest was not an exceptional remedy ([16]; [34]; [36]–[38]).
Hirachand v Hirachand established that success fees could not be recovered through substantive relief under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975. An order providing for that recovery was a prohibited costs order under section 58A(6) of the Courts and Legal Services Act 1990. That decision did not address the scope of the power to award pre-judgment interest or its interaction with section 58A(6). A compensatory interest award was distinct from an award of the success fee, whether through costs or substantive relief ([40]–[46]).
The contingent funding liability was a trigger permitting interest to be claimed. It did not determine the amount awarded. Interest depended on what funding the recoverable costs would reasonably have cost the relevant class of litigant, rather than the value of the success fee. The claimants therefore retained an incentive to limit their success fees. The adopted reasoning concerning post-judgment interest also supported the distinction between interest and recovery of funding costs themselves ([48]–[51]).
The former restriction in CPR rule 44.3B(1) on recovering the funding element of a success fee did not alter that conclusion. It was subject to a contrary court order and concerned recoverability of additional liabilities, rather than pre-judgment interest. BHP did not pursue orally its separate challenge to the exercise of discretion. The judge had been entitled to exercise that discretion in the claimants’ favour, and the interest award stood ([52]–[54]).
The court’s approach to earlier authorities
Available to signed-in members.
Appellate history
- Court of Appeal (Civil Division): [2026] EWCA Civ 1319 . BHP’s appeal against pre-judgment interest on the claimants’ Stage 1 costs was dismissed unanimously. Permission to appeal the substantive Stage 1 decisions had previously been refused.
- High Court, Technology and Construction Court: [2026] EWHC 73 (TCC) . Following the Stage 1 trial, O’Farrell J held BHP liable under Brazilian law and rejected its limitation defence. On 26 January 2026, she ordered payment of 90% of the claimants’ Stage 1 costs, pre-judgment interest at 1% above UK base rate, and £43 million on account of costs. She refused an immediate detailed assessment and permission to appeal the substantive decisions.
Appeal route
- Appealed from · 19 January 2026Município De Mariana v BHP Group (UK) Ltd & Anor[2026] EWHC 73 (TCC) High Court (Technology and Construction Court)UpheldAppeal dismissed unanimously.
- This judgment · 16 October 2026 [2026] EWCA Civ 1319 Court of Appeal (Civil Division)
Other judgments in these proceedings
27 judgments in these proceedings, earliest first. Linked by the shared court numbers HT-2022-000304 and HT-2023-000058, and by appeals.
- 20 April 2020Muncipio De Mariana & Ors v BHP Group Plc
- 22 more judgments in the full list below
- 19 January 2026Município De Mariana v BHP Group (UK) Ltd & Anor
- 16 March 2026BHP Group (UK) Ltd & Anor v Município de Mariana & Ors
- 6 May 2026Municipio de Mariana & Ors v BHP Group (UK) Ltd & Anor
- 16 October 2026Município de Mariana v BHP Group (UK) Ltd & Anor
All 27 judgments
- 20 April 2020Muncipio De Mariana & Ors v BHP Group Plc
- 18 September 2020Municipio De Mariana & Ors v BHP Group Plc & Anor
- 9 November 2020Municípo de Mariana v BHP Group PLC & Anor.
- 29 January 2021Municipio De Mariana & Ors v BHP Group PLC & Anor (Rev 1)
- 27 July 2021Municipio de Mariana v BHP Group plc (Practice Note)
- 8 July 2022Município de Mariana v BHP Group (UK) Ltd & Anor.
- 21 December 2022Município De Mariana v BHP Group (Uk) Limited & Anor.
- 12 May 2023Município de Mariana & Ors v BHP Group (UK) Limited & Anor
- 28 July 2023Município de Mariana & Ors v BHP Group (UK) Ltd & Anor
- 7 August 2023Município de Mariana & Ors v BHP Group (UK) Limited & Anor
- 19 October 2023Munícipio de Mariana v BHP Group (UK) Limited & Anor
- 24 November 2023Vale SA v BHP Group (UK) Ltd & Anor
- 21 December 2023Município de Mariana & Ors v BHP Group (UK) Ltd & Anor
- 11 January 2024Município De Mariana & Ors v BHP Group (UK) Limited (formerly BHP Group PLC) & Anor
- 31 January 2024Município de Mariana & Others v BHP Group (UK) Ltd and BHP Group plc & Anor
- 1 February 2024Município de Mariana & Others v BHP Group (UK) Ltd and BHP Group plc & Anor
- 18 April 2024Município de Mariana & Ors v BHP Group (UK) Ltd & Anor (Ruling on disclosure)
- 18 April 2024Município de Mariana & Ors v BHP Group (UK) Ltd & Anor (Ruling on interview notes)
- 18 April 2024Município de Mariana & Ors v BHP Group (UK) Ltd & Anor (Ruling on Model C disclosure)
- 18 April 2024Município de Mariana & Ors v BHP Group (UK) Ltd & Anor (Ruling on sample agreements)
- 26 June 2025Município de Mariana v BHP Group (UK) Limited & Anor
- 11 July 2025MUNICÍPIO DE MARIANA v BHP GROUP (UK) LIMITED
- 14 November 2025Município De Mariana v BHP Group (UK) Limited & Anor
- 19 January 2026Município De Mariana v BHP Group (UK) Ltd & Anor
- 16 March 2026BHP Group (UK) Ltd & Anor v Município de Mariana & Ors
- 6 May 2026Municipio de Mariana & Ors v BHP Group (UK) Ltd & Anor
- 16 October 2026Município de Mariana v BHP Group (UK) Ltd & Anor
Cases on related points
- Involnert Management Inc v Aprilgrange Limited & OrsRelies on 2 of the same authorities
- Southern Counties Fresh Foods Ltd, ReRelies on 2 of the same authorities
- Chodiev & Ors v SteinRelies on 2 of the same authorities
Key cases cited
10 authorities cited.
- Hirachand v Hirachand & another [2024] UKSC 43
- Secretary of State for the Department of Energy And Climate Change & Anor v Jones & Ors [2014] EWCA Civ 363
- Simcoe v Jacuzzi UK Group Plc [2012] EWCA Civ 137
- Bim Kemi AB v Blackburn Chemicals Ltd. [2003] EWCA Civ 889
- McPhilemy v Times Newspapers Ltd (No 2) [2001] EWCA Civ 933
- Nosworthy v Royal Bournemouth & Christchurch NHS Foundation Trust [2020] EWHC B19 (costs)
- Fattal & Anor v Walbrook Trustees (Jersey) Ltd & Anor (Rev. 1) [2009] EWHC 1674 (Ch)
- Fosse Motor Engineers Ltd & Ors v Conde Nast & National Magazine Distributors Ltd & Ors [2008] EWHC 2527 (QB)
- Nova Production Limited v Mazooma Games Limited [2006] EWHC 189 (Ch)
- Hunt v RM Douglas (Roofing) Ltd [1990] 1 AC 398
Sign in to see how the court treated each authority. A free account is enough.
Cases citing this case
Available to signed-in members.