Barry McCaffrey & Anor v Chief Constable of Police Service of Northern Ireland & Ors

[2026] EWCA Civ 1374

Summary

The Investigatory Powers Tribunal has no inherent or statutory power to award costs under the existing legislation and rules. The general power to award compensation or make other orders concerns substantive remedies and does not authorise the Tribunal to construct a costs regime. Where costs have been reserved, their subsequent determination forms part of the determination of the proceedings and is appealable. A respondent’s conduct which prolongs and aggravates a human rights violation may justify a somewhat greater award of compensation. Such an adjustment addresses the aggravated injury and does not produce the same consequences as a costs order.

Factual background

The appellants were journalists who had investigated the Loughinisland murders and produced a documentary. Following police investigations into the disclosure of documents used in the film, they brought human rights proceedings and surveillance complaints before the Investigatory Powers Tribunal. The Tribunal found that the Police Service of Northern Ireland had acted unlawfully, quashed a directed surveillance authorisation and awarded each journalist £4,000: [2024] UKIPTrib 8.

The journalists sought the costs wasted through two ineffective hearings caused by late and inadequate police disclosure. Costs had been reserved at those hearings and when the substantive judgment was delivered. A five-member Tribunal subsequently decided that it lacked jurisdiction to award costs. It also declined to increase compensation to reflect the expenditure. The Tribunal refused permission to appeal, considering its costs decision unappealable. Following an order for a rolled-up hearing, the Court of Appeal considered whether it had appellate jurisdiction, whether the Tribunal possessed a costs power and whether its refusal to increase compensation involved an error of law.

Held

Appeal dismissed unanimously.

  1. The Court of Appeal had jurisdiction to hear the appeal. Under sections 67A(1) and 68(4) of the Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act 2000, the decision on reserved costs formed part of the determination of the complaints. The substantive judgment had not completed the Tribunal’s work or rendered it functus officio. The position was equivalent to an application for costs made immediately after delivery of that judgment. The permission contemplated by the earlier appellate order therefore took effect (paras 31–33).

  2. The Tribunal had no inherent power to award costs, and neither the Act nor its rules expressly conferred that power. The general language of section 67(7) did not supply it. Every listed example of an available order concerned a substantive remedy. Neither that provision nor section 68 authorised the creation of a costs jurisdiction (paras 53–54).

  3. The proposed implication also left the content of any costs regime uncertain. A general discretion might suggest that costs should follow the event. That approach would be unfair to applicants who commonly lacked access to information available to the Tribunal. A tailored regime could take several forms, including restrictions based on unreasonable conduct or confinement to orders against respondents. The Secretary of State could introduce such rules, but the Tribunal could not construct that scheme through judicial decision-making. Doing so would undermine legal certainty (paras 55–56).

  4. The Tribunal’s refusal to increase compensation disclosed no error of law. The court endorsed the approach in Dias v Chief Constable of Cleveland Police. Conduct which prolonged and aggravated a human rights violation could justify a somewhat greater monetary award of just satisfaction. The consequences would differ from those of a costs order. The Strasbourg award of domestic legal costs in Associated Society of Locomotive Engineers and Firemen (ASLEF) v United Kingdom, (2007) 45 EHRR 34, did not establish that a domestic tribunal lacking statutory costs jurisdiction should make equivalent awards. Having already assessed compensation, the Tribunal was entitled to decline an increase in the circumstances (paras 57–62).

The court’s approach to earlier authorities

Available to signed-in members.

Appellate history

  • Court of Appeal (Civil Division): In [2026] EWCA Civ 1374 , held that the reserved costs decision was appealable and dismissed both grounds of appeal.
  • Investigatory Powers Tribunal: On 17 June 2025, refused permission to appeal, considering the costs decision unappealable and the proposed appeal without a real prospect of success.
  • Investigatory Powers Tribunal: On 17 April 2025, a five-member panel decided that it lacked jurisdiction to award costs and declined to increase compensation.
  • Investigatory Powers Tribunal: On 17 December 2024, in [2024] UKIPTrib 8, quashed a directed surveillance authorisation, awarded each appellant £4,000 and reserved costs.

Appeal route

  1. Appealed fromNot stated in the judgmentThis appealappeal dismissed unanimously.
  2. This judgment · 29 October 2026 [2026] EWCA Civ 1374 Court of Appeal (Civil Division)

Key cases cited

7 authorities cited.

  • C7 v Secrtary of State for the Home Department [2023] EWCA Civ 265
  • Global Santa Fe Drilling (North Sea) Ltd v Lord Advocate [2009] CSIH 43
  • Associated Society of Locomotive Engineers and Firemen (ASLEF) v United Kingdom (2007) 45 EHRR 34
  • Chatwani v National Crime Agency
  • Chatwani v National Crime Agency
  • Dias v Chief Constable of Cleveland Police
  • W v Public Authority IPT/09/134/C

Sign in to see how the court treated each authority. A free account is enough.

Cases citing this case

Available to signed-in members.