Summary
A bankruptcy petition founded on a foreign judgment cannot proceed where the debt is disputed on genuine and substantial grounds. Allegations of judicial predetermination attract the ordinary threshold for disputing a petition debt. There is no heightened evidential standard merely because a foreign judgment is challenged. Predetermination need not involve a deliberately incorrect decision, and the debtor need not show that every foreign appellate judgment was deliberately wrong. Hearsay is admissible evidence of the matters reported. Its weight must be assessed alongside the other evidence, including relevant expert evidence. A challenge based on fraud does not require prior pursuit of foreign remedies, although foreign judgments and the failure to raise the complaint abroad may remain evidentially relevant.
Factual background
Servis-Terminal LLC, a Russian company in bankruptcy acting through its trustee, obtained a Russian judgment requiring its former Director General and shareholder, Mr Drelle, to pay RUB 2 billion for losses arising from a loan. Three Russian appellate challenges were unsuccessful. The company subsequently served a statutory demand and presented an English bankruptcy petition.
Mr Drelle disputed the debt on grounds including judicial predetermination, fraud and breaches of natural justice. He relied on a former finance director’s double-hearsay account of a court chairman predicting the outcome, together with expert evidence concerning state influence and alleged defects in the Russian proceedings. ICC Judge Burton rejected the challenge in [2023] EWHC 506 (Ch), and a bankruptcy order followed. Richards J dismissed an appeal in [2024] EWHC 521 (Ch).
The Court of Appeal initially allowed a further appeal on the ground that an unrecognised foreign judgment could not constitute a petition debt: [2025] EWCA Civ 62. The Supreme Court reversed that decision and remitted the remaining grounds: [2026] UKSC 29. Those grounds concerned appellate review and the treatment of the factual and expert evidence. Separate recognition proceedings had been stayed pending this appeal.
Held
Appeal allowed on grounds (3) and (4); bankruptcy order set aside. Miles LJ gave the leading judgment, with which Falk and Newey LJJ agreed.
- A bankruptcy petition cannot proceed where the debt is disputed on genuine and substantial grounds. The inquiry is whether the dispute is real rather than frivolous or remote. Insolvency proceedings ordinarily lack the procedural machinery needed to determine substantial factual disputes. Evidence may nevertheless be rejected for inherent implausibility or because of the documentary record (paras 87–89).
- The civil standard at a trial challenging a foreign judgment is the balance of probabilities. Serious allegations require a properly identified evidential foundation, assessed against their underlying probability or improbability. Neither international comity nor the involvement of a foreign judgment creates a heightened standard. At the bankruptcy stage, the single question remains whether there is a genuine dispute on substantial grounds (paras 98–100).
- A challenge alleging judicial predetermination does not require proof that the judge deliberately reached an incorrect decision. A biased judge may produce a legally correct judgment. Maximov concerned an inference of bias drawn solely from alleged errors; its wider formulation requiring deliberate error was rejected. There was likewise no requirement to establish deliberate error in every foreign appellate judgment (paras 101, 132).
- The ICC judge erred in treating double hearsay as incapable of proving the matters reported and as lacking weight merely because it was hearsay. The evidence was admissible under section 1 of the Civil Evidence Act 1995. Its strengths, weaknesses and weight required evaluation. The further requirement for cogent evidence of a good arguable case also misstated the bankruptcy threshold. These legal errors required consideration of remittal or remaking rather than appellate deference to an evaluative decision (paras 103–107).
- The court remade the decision on the written evidence. The factual account, considered with the expert evidence, raised a realistically arguable case of predetermination. The suggested gaps were matters capable of exploration in cross-examination rather than decisive answers. The prediction preceded the possible receipt of further evidence and identified the amount eventually awarded. The expert evidence supplied relevant support when assessed cumulatively (paras 113–125, 135–137).
- Under Adams v Cape Industries Plc, a fraud challenge did not require prior pursuit of foreign remedies. Whether judicial predetermination should ultimately be classified as fraud or breach of natural justice remained open, but the fraud classification was sufficiently arguable. Foreign appellate reasoning and the failure to complain abroad remained evidentially relevant. Their force did not make this challenge fanciful or remote (paras 129–136).
The genuine and substantial dispute should be determined in the recognition proceedings, with disclosure and cross-examination available. Ground (2) did not arise (paras 137–140).
The court’s approach to earlier authorities
Available to signed-in members.
Appellate history
- Court of Appeal (Civil Division): On remittal, allowed the appeal on grounds (3) and (4) and set aside the bankruptcy order: [2026] EWCA Civ 1390 .
- Supreme Court: Allowed the company’s appeal, held that the payment obligation under an unrecognised foreign judgment could constitute a debt under section 267 of the Insolvency Act 1986, and remitted the remaining grounds: [2026] UKSC 29 ; [2026] 3 WLR 357.
- Court of Appeal (Civil Division): Initially allowed Mr Drelle’s appeal on the unrecognised-judgment ground without addressing the remaining grounds: [2025] EWCA Civ 62 ; [2026] Ch 1; [2025] BPIR 564.
- High Court, Insolvency and Companies List: Richards J dismissed the appeal against the bankruptcy order: [2024] EWHC 521 (Ch) ; [2024] BPIR 496.
- High Court, Insolvency and Companies List: ICC Judge Burton rejected the contention that the debt was disputed on genuine and substantial grounds: [2023] EWHC 506 (Ch); [2024] BPIR 285. A bankruptcy order was subsequently made.
Appeal route
- Appealed from · 11 March 2024Valeriy Ernestovich Drelle v Servis-Terminal LLC[2024] EWHC 521 (Ch) High Court (Insolvency and Companies List)This appealappeal allowed on grounds (3) and (4); bankruptcy order set aside.
- This judgment · 30 October 2026 [2026] EWCA Civ 1390 Court of Appeal (Civil Division)
Other judgments in these proceedings
5 judgments in these proceedings, earliest first. Linked by appeals and by the court numbers the judgments share.
- 11 March 2024Valeriy Ernestovich Drelle v Servis-Terminal LLC
- 31 January 2025Servis-Terminal LLC v Valeriy Ernestovich Drelle
- 5 June 2025Servis-Terminal LLC v Valeriy Ernestovich Drelle
- 27 July 2026Valeriy Ernestovich Drelle v Servis-Terminal LLC (In Liquidation in the Russian Federation)
- 30 October 2026[2026] EWCA Civ 1390
Cases on related points
- Crane Bank Limited & Ors v DFCU Bank Limited & OrsRelies on 2 of the same authorities
- Public Joint Stock Company ("Rosgosstrakh") v Starr Syndicate Ltd & OrsRelies on 2 of the same authorities
- Zhiming Huang & Ors v Credit Suisse (UK) LimitedRelies on 2 of the same authorities
1 more related case for signed-in readers. A free account is enough.
Key cases cited
11 authorities cited.
- TUI UK Ltd v Griffiths [2023] UKSC 48
- AK Investment CJSC v Kyrgyz Mobil Tel Limited and others (Isle of Man) [2011] UKPC 7
- Shafiq Malik v Henley Homes PLC [2023] EWCA Civ 726
- Koza Ltd & Anor. v Koza Altin Işletmeleri AS [2022] EWCA Civ 1284
- Kireeva v Bedzhamov (Vneshprombank LLC v Bedzhamov) [2022] EWCA Civ 35
- Bank St Petersburg PJSC & Anor v Arkhangelsky & Anor [2020] EWCA Civ 408
- Allied Fort Insurance Services Ltd & Ors v Creation Consumer Finance Ltd (t/a 'Premium First') [2015] EWCA Civ 841
- Yukos Capital SARL v OJSC Rosneft Oil Company [2012] EWCA Civ 855
- Bryce Ashworth v Newnote Limited [2007] EWCA 793
- Maximov v Open Joint Stock Company "Novolipetsky Metallurgichesky Kombinat" [2017] EWHC 1911 (Comm)
- Adams v Cape Industries plc [1990] Ch 433
Sign in to see how the court treated each authority. A free account is enough.
Cases citing this case
Available to signed-in members.