R E X v ALAN EUGINE HARRIS

[2026] EWCA Crim 1385

Summary

When sentencing multiple sexual offences against different victims, the central consideration is whether the overall sentence proportionately reflects the total criminality, taking account of all mitigating circumstances. Different combinations of consecutive and concurrent sentences may achieve that result. Consecutive sentences may be justified to mark the distinct harm suffered by individual victims. Repeated exploitation of a profoundly vulnerable client through a professional relationship of trust may justify a sentence above the ordinary category range. Previous good character may attract no real mitigation where offending has continued extensively over many years and professional reputation has enabled the exploitation. Advanced age and serious ill health remain relevant but do not necessarily make a substantial custodial sentence manifestly excessive.

Factual background

The applicant, a former criminal defence solicitor, was convicted after trial at Winchester Crown Court of ten offences of indecent assault or sexual assault against seven former clients. The offending extended over 27 years and involved vulnerable clients, several of whom were children or young people. Most assaults occurred in custody, where the clients depended on the applicant for legal advice and assistance in securing their release.

The sentencing judge imposed consecutive terms totalling 13 years’ imprisonment and ordered the remaining sentences to run concurrently. She reduced the aggregate sentence to reflect totality. Following refusal by the single judge, the applicant renewed his application for leave to appeal against four individual sentences and challenged the overall term. He relied on the nature of the touching, totality, his age, serious health conditions and previous good character. He also disputed the weight given to vulnerability and abuse of trust.

Held

The renewed application for leave to appeal against sentence was refused. The proposed appeal had no real prospect of success. The overall sentence of 13 years’ imprisonment was just and proportionate to the total criminality (paras [20]–[21]).

  1. There was no single correct way to structure sentences for offending of this kind. The central question was whether the overall term proportionately reflected the total criminality, taking all mitigating circumstances into account. A challenge to individual concurrent terms did not necessarily establish that the aggregate sentence was manifestly excessive. Concurrent sentences alone could not adequately mark the distinct harm to each complainant. The combination of consecutive and concurrent terms disclosed no error of principle (paras [17], [20]).
  2. The four-year sentence on count 17 fell within the category 2A range. It was justified by repeated offending against a client whose previous rape, serious mental health difficulties and fear of imprisonment were known to the applicant. The offending on counts 20 and 25 was even more grave. Repeated exploitation of a profoundly vulnerable young client, who had disclosed sustained sexual abuse, justified the five-year sentence on count 20 despite its exceeding the ordinary category 2A range. The concurrent two-year term on count 25 was also open to the judge (paras [14]–[15]).
  3. The three-year sentence on count 30 reflected the touching of naked genitalia and the total criminality against that complainant. The applicant’s asserted lack of knowledge that the complainant wore no underwear did not alter the intrinsic nature of the intentional sexual touching proved by the jury or render the sentence excessive (para [16]).
  4. The applicant’s advanced age and significant health conditions made imprisonment more difficult. Those matters, together with family circumstances and his fall from grace, had been fully reflected in the sentence. They did not make it manifestly excessive. Previous good character attracted no real mitigation in these circumstances: the extensive offending had continued over many years, and the applicant’s professional reputation had enabled his exploitation of vulnerable clients (paras [18]–[19]).

The court’s approach to earlier authorities

Available to signed-in members.

Appellate history

  • Court of Appeal (Criminal Division): In [2026] EWCA Crim 1385 , refused the renewed application for leave to appeal against sentence on 15 October 2026. The proposed appeal had no real prospect of success.
  • Single judge: Refused the initial application for leave to appeal against sentence.
  • Winchester Crown Court: Following conviction by a jury on 10 December 2025 of ten offences of indecent assault or sexual assault, Her Honour Judge Angela Morris imposed a total sentence of 13 years’ imprisonment on 25 February 2026.

Appeal route

  1. Appealed fromNot stated in the judgmentThis appealapplication refused
  2. This judgment · 15 October 2026 [2026] EWCA Crim 1385 Court of Appeal (Criminal Division)

Key cases cited

Available to signed-in members.

Cases citing this case

Available to signed-in members.