Summary
A public authority’s request for evidence is not a formal consultation merely because it uses that label or invites views from affected groups. The court considers the substance of the exercise, including its purpose, the nature and stage of the proposed decision, and whether consultees could respond to a sufficiently developed proposal. A duty to consult may arise from statute, a clear promise, an established practice tantamount to a promise, or exceptional circumstances in which non-consultation would be conspicuously unfair. A legitimate expectation based on a promise or practice requires clear and unqualified assurance. A decision-maker’s reliance on technical expert evidence and the adequacy of reasons are assessed in context, including the evidence available and the decision documents read together.
Factual background
Stilprime Ltd, a volumetric concrete mixer operator, and other operators brought a representative judicial review against the Secretary of State for Transport. They challenged the decision to let temporary higher weight limits for volumetric concrete mixers expire in 2028, requiring the vehicles thereafter to comply with ordinary heavy goods vehicle limits.
The Department for Transport had invited evidence on whether the policy should change and commissioned National Highways to study the effect of heavier mixers on bridges. The claimants argued that the process was an unfair consultation, that further consultation was required after the study and evidence responses became available, that reliance on the study was irrational, and that the reasons for the decision were inadequate. Permission to proceed was granted on all grounds. The central questions included whether the evidence exercise was a consultation and whether the decision was lawful.
Held
The claim was dismissed. The Call for Evidence was a voluntary exercise to gather information, not a common-law consultation. The description used in the documents did not determine its legal character. The court considered the exercise’s nature, purpose, content and stage. It ran alongside a National Highways study which the Department had said would inform the decision; respondents were not promised access to the study or a further opportunity to comment. The temporary weight arrangements were due to expire, so the claimants had no legitimate expectation that they would continue.
The Secretary of State was not under a separate legal duty to consult. There was no statutory duty or claim of conspicuous unfairness. The claimants identified no clear promise to consult, and their participation in earlier discussions and direct interest in the decision did not amount to a consistent practice tantamount to such a promise. The earlier process in 2014–2018 also involved an evidence exercise before a later engineering study, without a further consultation. The time available after the study and analysis were completed did not itself create a legal duty to consult.
The fairness requirements for consultation therefore did not arise. The related contention that the Secretary of State had predetermined the outcome also failed. Predetermination requires a closed mind rather than a genuine willingness to consider relevant arguments and evidence. Although the study ultimately carried significant weight, it had not been completed when the exercise began, and there was no evidence that the Secretary of State had decided in advance to treat it as determinative.
The irrationality challenge to the National Highways study failed. The Department gave a reasonable explanation for using desk-based modelling rather than gathering real-world loading data. The study’s authors did not say that real-world data was necessary before conclusions could be drawn, and the claimants produced no expert evidence or data showing that the methodology was manifestly wrong. On the choice between CS 454 and CS 458, the Secretary of State could rely on the experts’ approach: the subject was technical, the authors were experts, they used the method of the earlier unchallenged study, and they explained why the available data did not justify the CS 458 overload factors.
The reasons challenge also failed. The Department’s published outcome document, read alone, was manifestly inadequate. Read with the Minister’s letter of the same date, however, the reasons were clear and explained why the existing policy would remain: the evidence did not provide a compelling case for a permanent exemption, while the study indicated greater bridge loading and road wear, and only a small proportion of strategic road network bridges met the newer standards.
The court dismissed the claim. Consequential matters, including costs, were to be addressed by written submissions if not agreed.
The court’s approach to earlier authorities
Available to signed-in members.
Appellate history
Permission to proceed with the judicial review was granted on 3 September 2025. No earlier appellate decision is stated.
Cases on related points
- Medical Justice v The Secretary of State for the Home DepartmentRelies on 4 of the same authorities
- Medical Justice, R (on the application of) v Secretary of State for the Home DepartmentRelies on 3 of the same authorities
- Better Streets for Kensington and Chelsea & Anor., R (on the application of) v The Royal Borough of Kensington and ChelseaRelies on 2 of the same authorities
5 more related cases for signed-in readers. A free account is enough.
Key cases cited
14 authorities cited.
- R (Moseley) v Haringey London Borough Council (R (Stirling) v Haringey London Borough Council) [2014] UKSC 56
- R (on the application of Davies and another) v The Commissioners for Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs [2011] UKSC 47
- South Bucks District Council and another (Respondents) v. Porter (FC) (Appellant) [2004] UKHL 33
- Council of Civil Service Unions v Minister for the Civil Service [1985] AC 374
- The National Council for Civil Liberties, R (on the application of) v The Secretary of State for the Home Department [2025] EWCA Civ 571
- Secretary of State for Work and Pensions v Eveleigh & Ors [2023] EWCA Civ 810
- MP, R (On the Application Of) v Secretary of State for Health And Social Care [2020] EWCA Civ 1634
- Article 39, R (On the Application Of) v Secretary of State for Education (Rev 1) [2020] EWCA Civ 1577
- Bapio Action Ltd & Anor, R (on the application of) v Secretary of State for the Home Department & Anor [2007] EWCA Civ 1139
- R v North and East Devon Health Authority, Ex p Coughlan [1999] EWCA Civ 1871
- R (Plantagenet Alliance Ltd) v Secretary of State for Justice [2014] EWHC 1662 (Admin)
- R (Association of Personal Injury Lawyers) v Secretary of State for Justice [2013] EWHC 1358 (Admin)
- R v Devon County Council, Ex p Baker [1995] 1 All ER 73
- R v Brent London Borough Council, ex parte Gunning (1985) 84 LGR 168
Sign in to see how the court treated each authority. A free account is enough.
Cases citing this case
Available to signed-in members.