Tessa Shaw & Anor v Alexandra Stephani

[2026] EWHC 2776 (Admin)

Summary

The appropriate forum is identified by a holistic assessment of the connecting factors and the likely shape of the trial, asking where the case can best be tried for the parties and the ends of justice. For a tort claim, the place of commission is the starting point and normally provides a prima facie basis for that forum, subject to countervailing factors. The governing law matters to the extent that legal issues are likely to arise. A claimant’s residence, the location of continuing losses, witness convenience and the parties’ ability to travel are assessed in context; no single factor is automatically decisive. A more favourable damages regime and the availability of qualified one-way costs shifting carry little or no weight as juridical advantages. Funding concerns do not affect the assessment where the claimant does not contend that substantial justice is unavailable in the alternative forum.

Factual background

The claim arose from a 2023 road traffic accident in Shropshire. The driver responsible died at the scene. The two injured claimants, who live and work in Melbourne, brought proceedings against his mother as administratrix of his estate. Liability had been admitted before proceedings were issued.

The defendant applied to set aside the claim form and service and sought a declaration that the English court lacked jurisdiction. She contended that Victoria was the appropriate forum for the trial of damages, given the claimants’ residence, continuing treatment and future losses in Australia. The claimants relied on the accident and initial injuries in England, English law, and their other connections with this jurisdiction. The issue was whether England and Wales was clearly and distinctly the appropriate forum for the quantum trial.

Held

  1. Application refused. The claimants established that England and Wales was clearly and distinctly the appropriate forum for the trial of quantum. The court conducted an evaluative, holistic assessment of connecting factors and the likely shape of the trial, asking where the case could most suitably be tried for the parties and the ends of justice. It applied the approach stated in Spiliada Maritime Corporation v Cansulex Limited [1987] AC 460, Lungowe and others v Vedanta Resources plc and another [2019] UKSC 20, and Limbu and others v Dyson Technology Limited and others [2024] EWCA Civ 1564.

  2. The accident and initial injuries in England were important connecting factors. The place where a tort was committed is the starting point and will normally provide a prima facie basis for treating that place as the appropriate jurisdiction, unless countervailing considerations arise. English law was also a positive and significant connection, but its weight was limited because the likely disputes were mainly factual. The possible issue under section A1(2) of the Damages Act 1996 did not make the relevant Australian investment evidence too complex for an English court.

  3. The claimants’ residence, continuing treatment and substantial future losses connected the claim to Australia. Those factors were balanced against the accident, injuries and initial losses in England, the claimants’ genuine ties here, and their willingness and ability to attend a London trial. The decisions in Cooley v Ramsey [2008] EWHC 129 (QB), Wink v Croatia Osiguranje DD [2013] EWHC 1118 (QB) and Stylianou v Toyoshima [2013] EWHC 2166 (QB) concerned the damage gateway for service out and turned on their own facts. In those cases, severe injuries made travel to the accident forum difficult; that was not so here.

  4. Disclosure was neutral. The claimants’ attendance and their English-based case manager marginally favoured England. Other factual witnesses and experts could give evidence remotely, and the location of expert witnesses was neutral. The likely trial issues and the practical demands of the evidence informed the assessment.

  5. The role of Direct Line, although it was not a party, was relevant because it funded and conducted the defence, but carried less weight than the principal connecting factors. The prospect of a higher damages award and the availability of qualified one-way costs shifting carried little or no weight as juridical advantages. Funding did not need to be considered because the claimants did not contend that they would be unable to obtain substantial justice in Australia.

The court’s approach to earlier authorities

Available to signed-in members.

Appellate history

This was a first-instance jurisdiction application. The judgment identifies no prior court decision. The defendant’s application to set aside the claim form and service and to obtain a declaration that the court lacked jurisdiction was refused.

Other judgments in these proceedings

2 judgments in these proceedings, earliest first. Linked by the shared court number KB-2026-000554, and by appeals.

  1. 28 October 2026Tessa Shaw & Anor v Alexandra Stephani[2026] EWHC 2776 (Admin) · High Court (Administrative Court) · this judgment
  2. 28 October 2026Tessa Shaw & Anor v Alexandra Stephani[2026] EWHC 2776 (KB) · High Court (King's Bench Division)

Cases on related points

  1. Mercedes-Benz Group AG & Anor. v Continental Teves UK Limited & Ors.[2023] EWHC 1143 (Comm) · High Court (Commercial Court)Relies on 3 of the same authorities
  2. Mariusz Szrek & Ors v DIV-ING DOO & Ors[2024] EWHC 219 (KB) · High Court (King's Bench Division)Relies on 2 of the same authorities
  3. Stylianou v Toyoshima[2013] EWHC 2188 (QB) · High Court (Queen's Bench Division)Relies on 3 of the same authorities

Key cases cited

8 authorities cited.

Sign in to see how the court treated each authority. A free account is enough.

Cases citing this case

Available to signed-in members.