Tessa Shaw & Anor v Alexandra Stephani

[2026] EWHC 2776 (KB)

Summary

Forum conveniens is determined by an evaluative assessment of the connecting factors, viewed holistically, to identify where the case can most suitably be tried in the interests of all parties and for the ends of justice. The place of a tort is a relevant starting point, while the weight of governing law depends on the legal issues likely to arise. The court must also consider the likely shape of the trial and practical convenience. A more favourable damages regime or costs protection will generally carry little weight. Funding in the alternative forum matters only exceptionally, where it bears on whether substantial justice can be obtained there. On the facts, England and Wales had the most real and substantial connection to the claim, so the jurisdiction challenge was refused.

Factual background

The claimants, Tessa Shaw and Matthew Greenwood-Nimmo, are Australian residents who sustained serious injuries in a road traffic accident on the A5 in Shropshire. The driver, Eric Stephani, died at the scene. The defendant, his mother and administratrix, is resident and domiciled in New York. Liability had been admitted before proceedings were issued, leaving the assessment of damages in dispute.

The defendant applied to set aside the claim form and its service and sought a declaration that the High Court had no jurisdiction. The claimants contended that England and Wales was the appropriate forum for the quantum trial; the defendant argued for Victoria, Australia. The central issue was which jurisdiction was the more appropriate forum in light of the claim's connections and the practical requirements of trial.

Held

  1. The application was refused. The claimants established that England and Wales was clearly and distinctly the appropriate forum for trial of their claims. The defendant's application to set aside the claim form and service, and for a declaration that the court lacked jurisdiction, therefore failed.
  2. The court conducted an evaluative, holistic assessment of the connecting factors. The task was to identify the forum with which the action had the most real and substantial connection and where it could suitably be tried for the interests of all parties and the ends of justice. The approach in Spiliada Maritime Corporation v Cansulex Limited [1987] AC 460, as summarised in Limbu and others v Dyson Technology Limited and others [2024] EWCA Civ 1564, and considered in Lungowe and others v Vedanta Resources plc and another [2019] UKSC 20, was applied.
  3. The accident, injuries and initial losses occurred in England. English law applied, although its weight was limited because the likely disputes were mainly factual. The more favourable English discount rate was not a reason to prefer England; if English law applied in Australia, evidence about Australian investment conditions might still be needed. The availability of QOWCS was likewise a juridical advantage carrying little weight. The parties’ residence and domicile pointed away from England, but the claimants had genuine family and professional connections here. The defendant’s son’s former residence in Wales was of historic relevance only.
  4. The court considered the anticipated trial. Disclosure was readily accessible in both countries. The claimants were willing and able to attend a London trial, and their UK-based case manager could give evidence there. Other witnesses and Australian experts could give evidence remotely. The location of the experts was neutral, as was the location of most other witnesses. Practical convenience therefore did not displace the English connections.
  5. The cases of Cooley v Ramsey [2008] EWHC 129 (QB), Wink v Croatia Osiguranje DD [2013] EWHC 1118 (QB) and Stylianou v Toyoshima [2013] EWHC 2166 (QB) concerned whether damage was sustained in England for the purpose of the jurisdictional gateway in CPR PD 6B. They turned on their facts, including the claimants’ difficulty travelling to the foreign forum, and did not establish a general rule for the present forum assessment.
  6. Funding was not a factor in the balance. Although funding arguments can exceptionally be relevant, the claimants did not contend that they could not obtain substantial justice in Australia. The court therefore refused the application.

The court’s approach to earlier authorities

Available to signed-in members.

Other judgments in these proceedings

2 judgments in these proceedings, earliest first. Linked by the shared court number KB-2026-000554, and by appeals.

  1. 28 October 2026Tessa Shaw & Anor v Alexandra Stephani[2026] EWHC 2776 (Admin) · High Court (Administrative Court)
  2. 28 October 2026Tessa Shaw & Anor v Alexandra Stephani[2026] EWHC 2776 (KB) · High Court (King's Bench Division) · this judgment

Cases on related points

  1. Mercedes-Benz Group AG & Anor. v Continental Teves UK Limited & Ors.[2023] EWHC 1143 (Comm) · High Court (Commercial Court)Relies on 3 of the same authorities
  2. Mariusz Szrek & Ors v DIV-ING DOO & Ors[2024] EWHC 219 (KB) · High Court (King's Bench Division)Relies on 2 of the same authorities
  3. Stylianou v Toyoshima[2013] EWHC 2188 (QB) · High Court (Queen's Bench Division)Relies on 3 of the same authorities

Key cases cited

8 authorities cited.

Sign in to see how the court treated each authority. A free account is enough.

Cases citing this case

Available to signed-in members.