Grand China Logistics Holding (Group) Co. Ltd v Spar Shipping AS (Rev 1)

[2016] EWCA Civ 982

Summary

An obligation to pay hire punctually under a standard-form time charterparty is an innominate term unless the contract clearly makes it a condition. An express right to withdraw the vessel does not, without more, confer a right to loss-of-bargain damages.

Persistent defaults may nevertheless amount to renunciation. The question is whether the charterer objectively evinces an intention to perform in a manner substantially inconsistent with the contract, so that the owner would be deprived of substantially the whole contractual benefit. An intention to replace advance payment with substantial, continuing payment in arrears may satisfy that test. Inability to perform can negative contractual intention as effectively as an express refusal.

Treatment over time

Cited in 11 later judgments between 2017 and 2026. Applied, followed or approved 9 times, most recently by the High Court in July 2026.

Most often cited for

  1. Contractual terms are innominate unless clear construction shows otherwise, especially where breach consequences vary4 judgments
  2. Renunciation requires objectively demonstrated future non-performance that would deprive the other party of substantially the contract’s benefit3 judgments
  3. An express termination right does not itself make an obligation a condition or confer repudiatory consequences3 judgments

Factual background

The respondent shipowner let three vessels to a subsidiary of the appellant under time charterparties requiring semi-monthly hire in advance. The appellant guaranteed the charterer’s obligations. Following substantial and persistent arrears, the owner withdrew the vessels and claimed unpaid hire and damages for the remaining charter periods.

Popplewell J held in [2015] EWHC 718 (Comm) that punctual payment was not a condition, but that the charterer had renounced the charterparties. He awarded approximately US$25.3 million, interest and arbitration costs under the guarantees.

The guarantor appealed on renunciation. By respondent’s notice, the owner contended that punctual payment was a condition. The Court of Appeal therefore considered both the classification of the payment term and whether the charterer’s past defaults, financial position and projected future performance objectively amounted to renunciation.

Held

  1. The appeal was dismissed unanimously. The respondent’s notice was rejected. The obligation to pay hire punctually under clause 11 was an innominate term, but the charterer’s conduct amounted to renunciation of all three charterparties.

  2. Whether a contractual term is a condition is a question of construction. The modern approach treats a term as innominate unless the contract makes clear, expressly or by necessary implication, that it is a condition or warranty. Clause 11 did not make time of payment of the essence or state that every default would attract common-law loss-of-bargain damages. The potential consequences of late payment ranged from trivial to grave, which was characteristic of an innominate term.

  3. The express withdrawal clause gave the owner a contractual option to end future performance. Its inclusion did not establish that punctual payment was a condition. Contractual termination rights may arise upon breaches which are not repudiatory. The anti-technicality provision merely protected charterers against withdrawal following specified accidental defaults; it did not convert the payment obligation into a condition.

  4. Commercial certainty did not require a different construction. The withdrawal clause itself provided substantial certainty. Treating every payment default as a breach of condition would attach disproportionate loss-of-bargain consequences to trivial delays. The court therefore held that The Astra [2013] EWHC 865 (Comm) had been wrongly decided on this issue.

  5. Renunciation is established where words or conduct would lead a reasonable person to conclude that a party intends not to perform future obligations, or intends performance substantially inconsistent with the contract, and the threatened departure would deprive the innocent party of substantially the whole contractual benefit. An inability to perform may negative an intention to perform. Past breaches may assist in determining objectively what future performance is intended.

  6. The trial judge was entitled to find renunciation. Almost every instalment over more than five months had been late or unpaid. Arrears commonly stood between US$1.5 million and US$2.5 million despite liens, assurances had repeatedly failed, and no concrete source or timetable for sufficient funding was provided. The charterer objectively proposed continuing payment late and in arrears, dependent upon market conditions. That would transform a bargain for advance payment into unsecured, interest-free credit and deprive the owner of substantially the whole contractual benefit.

The court’s approach to earlier authorities

Available to signed-in members.

Appellate history

  1. Court of Appeal (Civil Division): In [2016] EWCA Civ 982 , unanimously dismissed the guarantor’s appeal on renunciation and rejected the shipowner’s respondent’s notice contending that punctual payment of hire was a condition.
  2. High Court, Commercial Court: Popplewell J held in [2015] EWHC 718 (Comm) that punctual payment was not a condition, but that the charterer had renounced the charterparties. Judgment was entered against the guarantor for unpaid hire, loss-of-bargain damages, interest and arbitration costs.

Appeal route

  1. Appealed from · 18 March 2015Spar Shipping AS v Grand China Logistics Holding (Group) Co, Ltd[2015] EWHC 718 (Comm) High Court (Commercial Court)UpheldAppeal dismissed unanimously; respondent’s notice rejected
  2. This judgment · 7 October 2016 [2016] EWCA Civ 982 Court of Appeal (Civil Division)

Other judgments in these proceedings

2 judgments in these proceedings, earliest first. Linked by appeals and by the court numbers the judgments share.

  1. 18 March 2015Spar Shipping AS v Grand China Logistics Holding (Group) Co, Ltd[2015] EWHC 718 (Comm) · High Court (Commercial Court)
  2. 7 October 2016Grand China Logistics Holding (Group) Co. Ltd v Spar Shipping AS (Rev 1)[2016] EWCA Civ 982 · Court of Appeal (Civil Division) · this judgment

Cases on related points

Of these 8 cases: 1 cited with it on one of its points; 3 cited alongside it for other points; 4 related in other ways.

Cited together forContractual terms are innominate unless clear construction shows otherwise, especially where breach consequences vary

  1. Bunge Corpn, New York v Tradax Export SA, Panama[1981] 1 WLR 711 · House of LordsCited together in 5 later judgments

Cited alongside it for other points

  1. Hongkong Fir Shipping Co Ltd v Kawasaki Kisen Kaisha Ltd (The Hongkong Fir)[1962] 2 QB 26 · Court of AppealA breach of an innominate term permits termination only if its consequences deprive the innocent party of substantially the whole contractual benefitCited together in 3 later judgments
  2. Wood v Capita Insurance Services Limited[2017] UKSC 24 · United Kingdom Supreme CourtContractual interpretation is a unitary exercise seeking the objective meaning of the parties’ languageCited together in 6 later judgments

+1 more for signed-in readers

Other related cases

4 related cases for signed-in readers

Key cases cited

The 30 most senior of 31 authorities cited.

Sign in to see how the court treated each authority and the other 1. A free account is enough.

Cases citing this case

11 later cases · 9 positive · 1 neutral · 1 caution

Most senior citing decisions:

Sign in for the full treatment table, including the other 1 cases. A free account is enough.