Motorola Solutions, Inc & Anor v Hytera Communications Corporation Ltd & Anor (Rev 1)

[2021] EWCA Civ 11

Cited by 11 later cases11 positiveCites 16 authorities

Summary

The unambiguous impropriety exception to without prejudice privilege requires proof of impropriety which is genuinely unambiguous. A good arguable case or plausible evidential basis does not suffice, even on an interim application. The court must rigorously scrutinise the evidence and protect the public interest in candid settlement negotiations.

A credible dispute about what was said or meant at an unrecorded settlement meeting will often prevent satisfaction of this demanding test. A threat to move assets beyond enforcement may qualify, but its character depends on the circumstances. Legitimate changes in business arrangements do not necessarily constitute impropriety.

A freezing injunction requires solid evidence of a real risk of unjustified dissipation. Dishonesty alone is insufficient unless it points towards the concealment or disposal of assets to frustrate enforcement.

Treatment over time

Cited in 11 later judgments between 2020 and 2026. Applied, followed or approved 11 times, most recently by the High Court in October 2026.

Most often cited for

  1. Without-prejudice privilege is displaced only by unambiguously established impropriety, not mere arguability11 judgments

Factual background

Motorola obtained a substantial jury verdict in United States trade-secret proceedings against Hytera. Before that judgment became enforceable, Motorola applied under section 25 of the Civil Jurisdiction and Judgments Act 1982 for domestic freezing injunctions against Hytera and its indirect subsidiary, Project Shortway Ltd.

Jacobs J granted injunctions against both companies in [2020] EWHC 980 (Comm). His conclusion that there was a real risk of dissipation depended on evidence of statements allegedly made by Hytera's former chief financial officer during without prejudice settlement meetings. He admitted that evidence because Motorola had a good arguable case that the statements amounted to unambiguous impropriety. The injunction against Shortway was granted under the Chabra jurisdiction.

The appeal concerned the evidential standard for the unambiguous impropriety exception, whether the alleged statements satisfied that standard, and whether the remaining evidence independently justified freezing relief.

Held

  1. Appeal allowed. The without prejudice evidence was inadmissible. The freezing injunctions against Hytera and Shortway were set aside.

  2. The unambiguous impropriety exception protects against abuse of the privileged occasion, but it is deliberately demanding. It requires nothing less than established unambiguous impropriety. A good arguable case or plausible evidential basis is insufficient, including on an interim application. The public interest in candid settlement negotiations outweighs the risk that some impropriety which cannot be proved unambiguously will remain protected.

  3. Evidence relied upon to disapply the privilege must be rigorously scrutinised. Where an unrecorded discussion is credibly disputed, the limitations of an interim hearing may prevent the court from finding unambiguous impropriety. The court should not take one party's disputed account at face value or direct satellite litigation to resolve what was said. The contrary approach in Dora v Simper was wrong in principle and should not be followed.

  4. A threat to transfer assets outside the ordinary and proper course of business so as to defeat enforcement may amount to unambiguous impropriety, but it does not invariably do so. Context remains essential. Here the alleged proposals included reducing surplus subsidiary cash, changing future credit terms and concentrating business in other markets. Those measures were not inherently improper. Hytera's explanation was at least as plausible as Motorola's account, so the evidence did not establish unambiguous impropriety.

  5. The remaining evidence did not independently justify a freezing order. Under the principles summarised in Lakatamia Shipping Co Ltd v Morimoto [2019] EWCA Civ 2203, the applicant needed solid evidence of a real, objectively assessed risk of unjustified dissipation. A good arguable case of dishonesty was insufficient unless the dishonesty pointed towards concealment or disposal of assets to frustrate enforcement. Jacobs J was entitled to find that threshold unmet.

  6. Once the injunction against Hytera was set aside, the Chabra issue concerning Shortway did not arise. The court reserved its opinion on whether such relief would otherwise have been appropriate.

The court’s approach to earlier authorities

Available to signed-in members.

Appellate history

  1. Court of Appeal (Civil Division): The appeal was allowed unanimously. The freezing injunctions against Hytera and Project Shortway Ltd were set aside: [2021] EWCA Civ 11 .
  2. High Court, Commercial Court: Jacobs J granted a domestic freezing injunction against Hytera under section 25 of the Civil Jurisdiction and Judgments Act 1982 and a Chabra injunction against Shortway: [2020] EWHC 980 (Comm) .

Appeal route

  1. Appealed from · 24 April 2020Motorola Solutions, Inc. & Ors v Hytera Communications Corporation Ltd & Ors[2020] EWHC 980 (Comm) High Court (Commercial Court)ReversedAppeal allowed unanimously; freezing orders against both appellants set aside
  2. This judgment · 11 January 2021 [2021] EWCA Civ 11 Court of Appeal (Civil Division)

Other judgments in these proceedings

2 judgments in these proceedings, earliest first. Linked by appeals and by the court numbers the judgments share.

  1. 24 April 2020Motorola Solutions, Inc. & Ors v Hytera Communications Corporation Ltd & Ors[2020] EWHC 980 (Comm) · High Court (Commercial Court)
  2. 11 January 2021Motorola Solutions, Inc & Anor v Hytera Communications Corporation Ltd & Anor (Rev 1)[2021] EWCA Civ 11 · Court of Appeal (Civil Division) · this judgment

Related cases

Not part of these proceedings, but heard together with this judgment or between the same parties.

  1. 11 November 2022Motorola Solutions, Inc & Anor v Hytera Communications Corportation Ltd & Ors[2022] EWHC 2887 (Comm) · High Court (Commercial Court) · Same parties
  2. 9 June 2023Motorola Solutions, Inc & Anor v Hytera Communications Corporation Ltd & Ors[2023] EWHC 1393 (Comm) · High Court (Commercial Court) · Same parties
  3. 3 November 2023Motorola v Hytera[2023] EWHC 2882 (Comm) · High Court (Commercial Court) · Same parties
  4. 19 January 2024Motorola Solutions, Inc & Anor v Hytera Communications Corporation Ltd & Ors[2024] EWHC 149 (Comm) · High Court (Commercial Court) · Same parties
  5. 14 November 2024Motorola Solutions, Inc & Anor v Hytera Communications Corporation Ltd & Ors[2024] EWHC 2891 (Comm) · High Court (Commercial Court) · Same parties
  6. 23 January 2025Motorola Solutions, Inc & Anor v Hytera Communications Corporation Ltd & Ors[2025] EWHC 257 (Comm) · High Court (Commercial Court) · Same parties
  7. 19 December 2025Motorola Solutions, Inc & Anor v Hytera Communications Corporation Ltd & Ors[2025] EWCA Civ 1667 · Court of Appeal (Civil Division) · Same parties

Cases on related points

Of these 8 cases: 2 cited with it on the same point; 2 cited alongside it for other points; 4 related in other ways.

Cited together forWithout-prejudice privilege is displaced only by unambiguously established impropriety, not mere arguability

  1. Unilever Plc v The Procter & Gamble Co[2000] 1 WLR 2436 · Court of AppealCited together in 7 later judgments
  2. Savings & Investment Bank Ltd. v Fincken[2003] EWCA Civ 1630 · Court of Appeal (Civil Division)Cited together in 4 later judgments

Cited alongside it for other points

  1. Ofulue and another (FC) v Bossert (FC)[2009] UKHL 16 · House of LordsThe without-prejudice rule is broad, and exceptions should remain limited to protect settlement negotiationsCited together in 3 later judgments

+1 more for signed-in readers

Other related cases

4 related cases for signed-in readers

Key cases cited

16 authorities cited.

Sign in to see how the court treated each authority. A free account is enough.

Cases citing this case

11 later cases · 11 positive

Most senior citing decisions:

Sign in for the full treatment table, including the other 1 cases. A free account is enough.