Olorunfunmilayo Oluwaseun Akinsanya v Secretary of State for the Home Department

[2022] EWCA Civ 37

Summary

A third-country national carer has no Zambrano right while domestic or other EU law supplies the residence, work or assistance necessary to prevent the dependent EU citizen from being compelled to leave EU territory. The right arises if that protection is lost and the practical compulsion condition is met.

Domestic legislation may nevertheless confer broader rights than EU law requires. There is no general presumption against such additional protection. Clear implementing legislation must be given its natural meaning. Under regulation 16 of the Immigration (European Economic Area) Regulations 2016, limited leave did not make a carer an exempt person. Such a carer could therefore hold a derivative right concurrently with limited leave.

Treatment over time

Cited in 8 later judgments between 2022 and 2025. Applied, followed or approved 4 times, most recently by the Court of Appeal in November 2025. 1 negative treatment, by the Upper Tribunal in 2023.

Most often cited for

  1. A Zambrano right requires no domestic right to reside and resulting compulsion to leave3 judgments

Factual background

The claimant, a Nigerian national and sole carer of a British citizen child, formerly held a derivative residence card as a Zambrano carer. She later obtained limited leave to remain and then applied for indefinite leave under the EU Settlement Scheme. The Secretary of State refused the application because the scheme's definition excluded a person holding leave granted outside that scheme.

Mostyn J allowed the claimant's judicial review, quashed the refusal and declared that the Secretary of State had misunderstood both EU law and regulation 16 of the Immigration (European Economic Area) Regulations 2016. The Secretary of State appealed. The questions were whether limited leave prevented a Zambrano right arising under EU law and whether regulation 16 nevertheless conferred a concurrent domestic derivative right.

Held

  1. Appeal dismissed in substance. The High Court's order quashing the refusal remained in force. The declaration was varied to state that the Secretary of State had erred in her understanding of regulation 16 when framing the EU Settlement Scheme definition.
  2. The EU-law ground succeeded. Zambrano rights are exceptional and contingent. They arise to prevent a dependent EU citizen from being compelled in practice to leave EU territory. Decisions including Iida and NA showed that the right does not arise while domestic law or another source of EU law supplies the necessary residence right. The practical possibility that the domestic right might later be lost does not alter that conclusion. If it is lost and removal would compel the EU citizen to leave, the Zambrano right arises: it remains, in the court's phrase, “waiting in the wings”.
  3. Sanneh did not establish a contrary rule. It concerned a carer who had no domestic residence right and rejected the contention that a Zambrano right arose only when removal became imminent. Its reasoning did not address a carer already possessing limited leave.
  4. The domestic-law ground failed. Regulation 16(7)(c)(iv) of the Immigration (European Economic Area) Regulations 2016 expressly made a person with indefinite leave an exempt person. Its clear language did not include a person holding only limited leave. Subject to the remaining statutory criteria, such a person could therefore acquire a derivative right concurrently with that leave.
  5. There is no general presumption that domestic legislation implementing EU law cannot go beyond the EU minimum. Whether the legislature intended additional protection is part of the ordinary contextual exercise of construction. Here, any broad intention merely to implement Zambrano could not justify adding words which would change the clear scope and meaning of regulation 16.

Bean and Andrews LJJ agreed with Underhill LJ.

The court’s approach to earlier authorities

Available to signed-in members.

Appellate history

  1. Court of Appeal (Civil Division): By [2022] EWCA Civ 37 , dismissed the appeal in substance, preserved the quashing order and substituted a more precisely framed declaration concerning regulation 16 of the Immigration (European Economic Area) Regulations 2016.
  2. High Court, Administrative Court: Mostyn J allowed the judicial review, quashed the Secretary of State's refusal and declared that the EU Settlement Scheme definition rested on errors concerning EU law and regulation 16. No neutral citation is stated in the judgment.

Appeal route

  1. Appealed fromNot stated in the judgmentThis appealappeal dismissed; declaration substituted
  2. This judgment · 25 January 2022 [2022] EWCA Civ 37 Court of Appeal (Civil Division)

Other judgments in these proceedings

2 judgments in these proceedings, earliest first. Linked by appeals and by the court numbers the judgments share.

  1. 9 June 2021R (Akinsanya) v Secretary of State for the Home Department[2021] EWHC 1535 (Admin) · High Court (Administrative Court)
  2. 25 January 2022Olorunfunmilayo Oluwaseun Akinsanya v Secretary of State for the Home Department[2022] EWCA Civ 37 · Court of Appeal (Civil Division) · this judgment

Cases on related points

Of these 5 cases: 2 cited alongside it for other points; 3 related in other ways.

Cited alongside it for other points

  1. Alban Velaj v The Secretary of State for the Home Department[2022] EWCA Civ 767 · Court of Appeal (Civil Division)Regulation 16 requires a fact-specific inquiry into whether the citizen would have to leaveCited together in 3 later judgments
  2. Patel v Secretary of State for the Home Department[2019] UKSC 59 · United Kingdom Supreme CourtAdult preference for family life or choice to follow a relative does not establish compulsion to leaveCited together in 3 later judgments

Other related cases

  1. Alban Velaj v The Secretary of State for the Home Department[2021] UKUT 235 (IAC) · Upper Tribunal (Immigration and Asylum Chamber)Relies on 3 of the same authorities

+2 more for signed-in readers

Key cases cited

13 authorities cited.

Sign in to see how the court treated each authority. A free account is enough.