Disclosure and Barring Service v RI

[2024] EWCA Civ 95

Summary

Under section 4(2)(b) of the Safeguarding Vulnerable Groups Act 2006, the Upper Tribunal may find that the Disclosure and Barring Service made a material mistake of fact where relevant oral evidence, assessed with the documentary evidence as a whole, establishes that the appellant did not commit the alleged act. The appellant need not identify a separate, granular error or introduce a previously undisclosed fact.

The Tribunal must not simply substitute its evaluation where it has substantially the same evidence as the DBS. That limitation does not apply where the appellant gives relevant oral evidence which the Tribunal can assess through cross-examination. Challenges which merely seek to reopen the Tribunal’s factual evaluation do not disclose an error of law.

Treatment over time

Cited in 71 later judgments between 2024 and 2026. Applied, followed or approved 63 times, most recently by the Upper Tribunal in October 2026.

Most often cited for

  1. Relevant oral evidence allows the Upper Tribunal to make its own factual findings69 judgments

Factual background

RI, a support worker for vulnerable adults, was included in the Adults’ Barred List after the Disclosure and Barring Service found, on the balance of probabilities, that she had stolen money from a service user in her care.

The Upper Tribunal heard RI give oral evidence, assessed her credibility, and found as a fact that she had not stolen money. It held that the DBS had made a material mistake of fact and directed that RI’s name be removed from the list.

The DBS appealed. Its principal contention was that the Upper Tribunal had impermissibly substituted its own view of substantially the same evidence, rather than identifying a mistake of fact within section 4(2)(b) of the Safeguarding Vulnerable Groups Act 2006.

Held

Decision

  1. The Court unanimously dismissed the DBS’s appeal. The Upper Tribunal had jurisdiction to find a material mistake of fact and to direct RI’s removal from the Adults’ Barred List.

  2. Section 4(2)(b) of the Safeguarding Vulnerable Groups Act 2006 permits an appellant to contend that the DBS was mistaken in finding that the appellant committed the relevant act. The statutory language does not require a separate or more granular factual mistake. Parliament contemplated that the Upper Tribunal could hear an appellant say that they did not do the act, evaluate that evidence with all the other evidence, and allow the appeal if persuaded on the balance of probabilities.

  3. The Tribunal could assess RI’s oral evidence, including how it stood up to cross-examination, even though she substantially repeated her written denial. That evidence was relevant and was not before the DBS when it made its paper-based decision. The Tribunal was therefore entitled to make its own findings of primary fact on the evidence as a whole. The approach in PF v DBS, [2020] UK UT 256 (AAC), remained good law.

  4. Disclosure and Barring Service v JHB, [2023] EWCA Civ 982, was confined to cases where the Upper Tribunal has the same, or materially the same, evidence as the DBS, or receives no oral evidence relevant to whether the alleged act was committed. In that situation, the Tribunal cannot merely substitute its factual assessment. It did not govern this appeal.

  5. Grounds 2 and 3 were attempts to reopen the Upper Tribunal’s factual assessment. The possibility that others had access to the service user’s finances was not material to the Tribunal’s primary conclusion. Nor did the Tribunal’s failure expressly to mention every item of evidence show that it had failed to consider it. Its findings were not vitiated by an error of law.

  6. As the DBS’s decision rested solely on the theft finding, and no other basis for listing RI had been advanced, the direction for removal was permissible under section 4(6)(a), consistently with AB v DBS, [2021] EWCA Civ 1575.

The court’s approach to earlier authorities

Available to signed-in members.

Appellate history

  1. Court of Appeal (Civil Division) — dismissed the DBS appeal and upheld the Upper Tribunal’s direction that RI be removed from the Adults’ Barred List: [2024] EWCA Civ 95 .

  2. Upper Tribunal (Administrative Appeals Chamber) — on 18 May 2022, allowed RI’s appeal, found that the DBS had made a mistake of fact in finding theft, and directed removal from the list.

  3. Disclosure and Barring Service — on 25 March 2020, decided to include RI in the Adults’ Barred List.

Appeal route

  1. Appealed fromNot stated in the judgmentThis appealappeal dismissed (unanimous)
  2. This judgment · 9 February 2024 [2024] EWCA Civ 95 Court of Appeal (Civil Division)

Often cited alongside this case

Of these 8 cases: 5 cited with it on the same point; 3 cited alongside it for other points.

Cited together forRelevant oral evidence allows the Upper Tribunal to make its own factual findings

  1. Disclosure and Barring Service v JHB[2023] EWCA Civ 982 · Court of Appeal (Civil Division)Cited together in 44 later judgments
  2. Patricia Kihembo v Disclosure and Barring Service[2023] EWCA Civ 1547 · Court of Appeal (Civil Division)Cited together in 23 later judgments

+3 more for signed-in readers

Cited alongside it for other points

  1. Khakh v Independent Safeguarding Authority[2013] EWCA Civ 1341 · Court of Appeal (Civil Division)The final decision letter and Barring Decision Summary together state the substantive decision and reasonsCited together in 19 later judgments

+2 more for signed-in readers

Key cases cited

11 authorities cited.

Sign in to see how the court treated each authority. A free account is enough.

Cases citing this case

71 later cases · 63 positive · 4 neutral · 4 caution

Most senior citing decisions:

Sign in for the full treatment table, including the other 61 cases. A free account is enough.