The Kingdom of Spain and another v The London Steam-Ship Owners’ Mutual Insurance Association Limited No 2

[2026] UKSC 36

Cited by 1 later case1 cautionCites 38 authorities

Summary

A third party who chooses to enforce a contractual right takes the related burdens governing its enforcement. An arbitration obligation arising through this conditional benefit principle is contractual. Its breach attracts the ordinary contractual remedies, including common law damages, rather than equitable compensation.

State immunity from injunctions does not preclude such damages. Although common law damages cannot compensate for breaches not yet committed, a conditional award may require payment when future losses arise from an existing breach. The unavailability of statutory damages in lieu of an injunction does not restrict those ordinary remedies. An arbitration appeal remains confined to the questions of law properly admitted and the tribunal’s findings of fact.

Factual background

The London Steam-Ship Owners’ Mutual Insurance Association Limited, a protection and indemnity insurer known as the Club, insured the owners and managers of the tanker Prestige. Following the tanker’s sinking and resulting coastal pollution, the Kingdom of Spain and the French State brought direct claims against the Club under article 117 of the Spanish Penal Code 1995. The insurance contract contained a London arbitration clause and a condition requiring the insured to discharge its liability before recovering from the Club.

Earlier English proceedings established that the States’ claims were contractual in substance and that pursuing them subjected the States to the arbitration clause. The States nevertheless obtained a Spanish judgment against the Club. Further London arbitrations awarded compensation for costs and conditional indemnities against losses arising from enforcement of that judgment. The arbitrators proceeded on the assumption that the States had breached equitable obligations to arbitrate.

Butcher J upheld the compensation awards while rejecting the availability of injunctions and damages in lieu: [2023] EWHC 2473 (Comm) and [2023] EWHC 2474 (Comm). The Court of Appeal set aside the relevant monetary awards: [2024] EWCA Civ 1536. The Club appealed on the availability of compensation and the statutory limits of arbitration appeals. The central issue was the nature of the arbitration obligation arising through the conditional benefit principle and the remedies available for its breach.

Held

  1. The appeal was unanimously allowed. Lord Leggatt and Lord Burrows delivered the joint judgment, with which the other justices agreed. Subject to variations clarifying their contractual basis, the monetary awards were to be confirmed without remission.

  2. The conditional benefit principle requires a third party choosing to assert a contractual right to accept the related burden. That burden retains its legal or equitable character and attracts the same remedies as against the original party. The principle imposes no independent obligation before that choice. This differs from a condition precedent, such as a pay to be paid clause, which imposes no obligation on the third party (paras 49–65).

  3. A third party asserting rights under a contract containing an arbitration clause is treated as a party to that clause for disputes concerning the claim. Its obligation is contractual, and breach attracts common law damages. The principle’s dependence on the third party’s choice does not confine relief to injunctions or declarations. Tito v Waddell (No 2) supplied the correct analysis. Properly understood, The Jay Bola supported that conclusion, although some references to equity were mistaken. The contrary statement about damages in Through Transport (No 1) was also wrong (paras 59–65, 75–89, 99–107).

  4. Equitable compensation was unavailable because the wrong was contractual. In principle, that remedy can compensate for any equitable wrong. The court also considered, obiter, that subrogation cannot transform a contractual arbitration obligation into an equitable obligation (paras 41–46, 92–96, 132).

  5. The immunity from injunctions under section 13(2)(a) of the State Immunity Act 1978 did not preclude common law damages. The unavailability of section 50 of the Senior Courts Act 1981 excluded damages for threatened future breaches, but left ordinary damages for accrued breaches intact. A court or tribunal could order payment conditionally when future losses from an existing breach arose (paras 108–116, 148–153).

  6. The Court of Appeal exceeded the limits of section 69 of the Arbitration Act 1996 by deciding causation and third-country comity questions outside the permitted appeals. Its substantive reasoning was also unsustainable. An adverse foreign judgment did not displace the breach of the arbitration obligation as an effective cause of loss. Compensation neither prevented foreign recognition or enforcement nor made comity relevant to the existence of the power to compensate (paras 117–130).

  7. Issue estoppel concerned only necessary and fundamental determinations forming the immediate foundation of an earlier decision. The earlier proceedings had determined neither the obligation’s legal character nor the monetary remedy. An erroneous legal classification could not justify withholding substantively available relief. The court could correct the shared legal assumption after giving the parties a fair opportunity to address it (paras 135–145).

  8. The same relief was inevitable on the contractual analysis. The awards were to be varied by an appropriate recital clarifying that basis. The inaccurate description of the obligation as equitable in the French award’s declarations was to be deleted (paras 146–155).

The court’s approach to earlier authorities

Available to signed-in members.

Appellate history

  1. Supreme Court: [2026] UKSC 36 . Allowed the Club’s appeal unanimously and directed confirmation of the awards subject to variations identifying their contractual basis.
  2. Court of Appeal: [2024] EWCA Civ 1536 ; [2025] 1 WLR 3011 . Allowed the States’ appeals against equitable compensation and set aside the relevant monetary awards. Upheld the conclusions that injunctions and damages in lieu were unavailable.
  3. High Court: Butcher J, [2023] EWHC 2473 (Comm) ; [2024] 1 WLR 2331 , concerning Spain, and [2023] EWHC 2474 (Comm) ; [2024] 2 All ER (Comm) 175, concerning France. Allowed the challenges to injunctive relief and damages in lieu, but dismissed the appeals against equitable compensation under section 69 of the Arbitration Act 1996.
  4. Arbitral tribunals: Sir Peter Gross made partial awards concerning Spain on 6 January and 27 March 2023. Dame Elizabeth Gloster made partial awards concerning France on 8 February and 2 May 2023. Both awarded monetary relief for breach of obligations to arbitrate, including conditional relief against future losses.

Appeal route

  1. Appealed from · 12 December 2024The Kingdom of Spain v The London Steam-Ship Owners' Mutual Insurance Association Limited[2024] EWCA Civ 1536 Court of Appeal (Civil Division)ReversedAppeal allowed unanimously; awards confirmed subject to variations, without remission.
  2. This judgment · 28 October 2026 [2026] UKSC 36 United Kingdom Supreme Court

Other judgments in these proceedings

9 judgments in these proceedings, earliest first. Linked by appeals and by the court numbers the judgments share.

  1. 29 January 2020Spain v The London Steam-Ship Owners' Mutual Insurance Association Ltd[2020] EWHC 142 (Comm) · High Court (Commercial Court)
  2. 18 December 2020The London Steam-Ship Owners' Mutual Insurance v The Kingdom of Spain[2020] EWHC 3540 (Comm) · High Court (Commercial Court)
  3. 12 May 2021The London Steam-Ship Mutual Insurance Association Ltd v The Kingdom of Spain (M/T PRESTIGE)[2021] EWHC 1247 (Comm) · High Court (Commercial Court)
  4. 1 March 2022The London Steam-Ship Owners' Mutual Insurance Association Limited v The Kingdom of Spain[2022] EWCA Civ 238 · Court of Appeal (Civil Division)
  5. 6 October 2023The London Steam-Ship Owners’ Mutual Insurance Association Limited v The Kingdom of Spain (M/T ‘Prestige’)[2023] EWHC 2473 (Comm) · High Court (Commercial Court)
  6. 6 October 2023The French State v The London Steam-Ship Owners’ Mutual Insurance Association Limited[2023] EWHC 2474 (Comm) · High Court (Commercial Court)
  7. 19 December 2023The French State v The London Steam-Ship Mutual Insurance Association Limited[2023] EWHC 3263 (Comm) · High Court (Commercial Court)
  8. 12 December 2024The Kingdom of Spain v The London Steam-Ship Owners' Mutual Insurance Association Limited[2024] EWCA Civ 1536 · Court of Appeal (Civil Division)
  9. 28 October 2026The Kingdom of Spain and another v The London Steam-Ship Owners’ Mutual Insurance Association Limited No 2[2026] UKSC 36 · Supreme Court · this judgment

Related cases

Not part of these proceedings, but heard together with this judgment or between the same parties.

  1. 17 October 2013The London Steam Ship Owners Mutual Insurance Association Ltd v The Kingdom of Spain[2013] EWHC 2840 (Comm) · High Court (Commercial Court) · Same parties
  2. 22 October 2013The London Steam-Ship Owners' Mutual Insurance Association Ltd v The Kingdom of Spain & Anor[2013] EWHC 3188 (Comm) · High Court (Commercial Court) · Same parties
  3. 1 April 2015The London Steamship Owners' Mutual Insurance Association Ltd v The Kingdom of Spain & Anor[2015] EWCA Civ 333 · Court of Appeal (Civil Division) · Same parties
  4. 18 June 2020The London Steam-Ship Owners' Mutual Insurance Association Ltd v Spain (M/T "PRESTIGE")[2020] EWHC 1582 (Comm) · High Court (Commercial Court) · Same parties
  5. 24 July 2020The London Steam-Ship Owners' Mutual Insurance Association Ltd v The Kingdom of Spain[2020] EWHC 1920 (Comm) · High Court (Commercial Court) · Same parties
  6. 4 November 2021London Steam-Ship Owners' Mutual Ins Assoc Ltd v Kingdom of Spain[2021] EWCA Civ 1589 · Court of Appeal (Civil Division) · Same parties

Cases on related points

  1. Shipowners' Mutual Protection And Indemnity Association (Luxembourg) v Containerships Denizcilik Nakliyat Ve Ticaret AS[2015] EWHC 258 (Comm) · High Court (Commercial Court)Relies on 4 of the same authorities
  2. Aline Tramp SA v Jordan International Insurance Company[2016] EWHC 1317 (Comm) · High Court (Commercial Court)Relies on 3 of the same authorities
  3. Fortress Value Recovery Fund I LLC v Blue Skye Special Opportunities Fund LP & Ors[2013] EWCA Civ 367 · Court of Appeal (Civil Division)Relies on 2 of the same authorities

Key cases cited

The 30 most senior of 38 authorities cited.

Sign in to see how the court treated each authority and the other 8. A free account is enough.

Cases citing this case

1 later case · 1 caution

Most senior citing decisions:

Sign in for the full treatment table. A free account is enough.