Summary
A libel claimant must plead the connecting facts on which identification depends where those facts go beyond the general knowledge reasonably attributed to a person acquainted with the claimant. Reference is assessed objectively from the reader’s perspective.
Serious harm must be pleaded separately for each discrete publication. The claimant must plead the facts relied on to establish harm or its likelihood; the gravity of the allegation alone is insufficient. Specific matters relied on in support of damages must also be pleaded.
Where a defective pleading may realistically be corrected, the court will normally give the claimant an opportunity to amend. A litigant’s public commentary on proceedings engages open justice and freedom of expression and does not, together with deficient pleading, necessarily amount to an abuse of process.
Factual background
Victoria Rixon, a midwife and maternity safety campaigner, brought libel claims against three fellow campaigners, Emily Barley, Heather Heath-Alton and Elizabeth Smith. The claims concerned two social media publications about the death of a baby and a midwife’s role in his care and subsequent campaigning. The publications did not name Rixon.
The defendants applied to strike out the claims, or for summary judgment. They said the particulars of claim failed adequately to plead identification, serious harm and damage. They also alleged abuse of process based on Rixon’s conduct of the litigation and her social media commentary. Rixon opposed the application and provided further factual information in a witness statement, but had not sought permission to amend her pleading.
Held
The application succeeded in part. The court rejected the allegation of abuse of process but struck out specified paragraphs of the particulars of claim, with an opportunity for the claimant to apply for permission to amend.
- Reference is an essential element of libel and is determined objectively. The question is whether a reasonable reader would understand the publication to refer to the claimant, not what its author intended. Where identification depends on particular connecting facts beyond the general knowledge attributable to an acquaintance, those facts and the basis for readers’ knowledge must be pleaded. The claimant’s pleading relied on the author’s understanding for the first publication and failed to identify the necessary connecting facts for either publication. Her witness statement identified facts that could have been pleaded. Dyson Technology Ltd v Channel Four Television Corporation [2023] EWCA Civ 884 and Bridgen v Hancock [2024] EWHC 623 (KB) considered.
- Under section 1(1) of the Defamation Act 2013, serious harm depends on the inherent tendency of the words and their actual impact or likely impact. Practice Direction 53B requires facts supporting serious harm to be pleaded separately for each discrete publication. The gravity of the allegations alone was insufficient. The claimant had identified potentially relevant facts in her witness statement.
- Practice Direction 53B requires specific facts relied on for damages to be pleaded, but does not require a claimant to rely on any particular facts. Aggravated or exemplary damages and their basis must be pleaded under rule 16.4(1)(c) of the Civil Procedure Rules 1998. The claimant’s sparse pleading failed adequately to particularise her case.
- The litigation conduct complained of, individually or cumulatively, did not amount to abuse. The claimant’s public commentary had caused the defendants distress, but litigants’ speech about their cases engages open justice and article 10 rights. Its combination with deficient pleading did not justify strike out. Restrictions on the use of disclosed documents and witness statements before deployment in open court remained applicable.
- Under rule 3.4(2)(c), paragraphs 8, 9, 10, 11, 15 and 16 of the particulars were struck out. The witness statement showed a potentially viable case if properly pleaded. The claimant was given a final opportunity to apply for permission to amend, with the burden of showing that each proposed amendment had a realistic prospect of success. If permission were granted, the defendants could seek consequential amendments to their defences.
The court’s approach to earlier authorities
Available to signed-in members.
Appellate history
The defendants applied for strike out and/or summary judgment after raising deficiencies in the particulars of claim. The claimant responded with a witness statement but did not apply to amend. The High Court struck out specified paragraphs and gave her an opportunity to apply for permission to amend.
Cases on related points
- Mohammed Hegab v The Spectator (1828) Limited & AnorRelies on 2 of the same authorities
- Keith Courtney v Richard RonksleyRelies on 2 of the same authorities
- Elizabeth Lynette Tattersall v Yvonne Marie TattersallRelies on 2 of the same authorities
5 more related cases for signed-in readers. A free account is enough.
Key cases cited
9 authorities cited.
- Lachaux v Independent Print Ltd and another [2019] UKSC 27
- Knuppfer v London Express Newspapers Ltd [1944] AC 116
- Hulton (E) & Co v Jones [1910] AC 20
- Dyson Technology Limited v Channel Four Television Corporation [2023] EWCA Civ 884
- Andrew Bridgen MP v Matthew Hancock MP [2024] EWHC 623 (KB)
- Mohamed Amersi v Charlotte Leslie & Anor. [2023] EWHC 1368 (KB)
- Monir v Wood [2018] EWHC 3525
- Kim v Park [2011] EWHC 1781 (QB)
- Handyside v United Kingdom
Sign in to see how the court treated each authority. A free account is enough.
Cases citing this case
Available to signed-in members.